Quantcast
Channel: ZODIAC CIPHERS - Zodiac News
Viewing all 1041 articles
Browse latest View live

DONNA LASS-TWO DAYS AFTER SPRING

$
0
0
The first three crimes of Lake Herman Road, Blue Rock Springs Park and Lake Berryessa were committed in situ, in that the Zodiac Killer attacked the couples where he discovered them. The Zodiac at Presidio Heights entered the taxicab of Paul Stine in the bustling theater district of San Francisco and murdered him at Washington and Cherry, although Paul Stine effectively remained in situ, within the taxicab throughout. The three crimes that have widely been attributed to Zodiac, are the Riverside murder of Cheri Jo Bates, the Modesto abduction of Kathleen Johns and the disappearance of Donna Lass from the Sahara Tahoe Casino, all of which were followed by alleged communications from the Zodiac Killer. These three crimes had one thing in common, the perpetrator used a ruse, to lure the women into his vehicle and remove them from the first point of contact. Cheri Jo Bates' car distributor was tampered with, followed by the promise of a lift home, to lure the young woman into his vehicle. Kathleen Johns, again would fall prey to the same tactic, her wheel was tampered with, followed by the promise of a lift to a service station. Donna Lass was lured away from her place of work, by a false medical emergency, to again draw the nurse toward his vehicle. Three crimes, involving three young women, and in all instances similar tactics were employed, followed by a correspondence claiming the crime. Here though, it is the Donna Lass abduction we shall concentrate on.
In the aftermath of the disappearance, the search for Donna Lass would be badly affected by the inclement weather in the coming months, highlighted by Police Chief Ray Lauritzen in the newspapers from the outset: "We don't know where we're going to begin. There's a four or five foot pack of snow out there and it's still snowing heavily. There's no point to a search at this time. It's unlikely a victim would be uncovered before spring."  
The Zodiac Killer, we know, was an avid reader of the newspapers, and it is likely he also read this statement by Chief Ray Lauritzen. It is possible the 'Pines' card, mailed on March 22nd 1971 was a direct response to this article, but in a very subtle way. This we will come to later.   
Picture
It is far from certain the perpetrator of this crime knew Donna Lass, but the following will explore reasons why this may be the case.  
Similar to the second and third crimes by the Zodiac Killer, the disappearance of Donna Lass was again followed by a phone call from the supposed perpetrator. But unlike Blue Rock Springs Park and Lake Berryessa, this phone call didn't brag about his crime, it claimed Donna Lass had been 'called away' or 'called out of town' due to a family illness, all of which was subsequently proved to be false. The caller was seemingly trying to give the impression nothing sinister had happened, suggesting the act of the phone call was simply to 'buy time'. If the abductor was affording himself some extra breathing space, then the real possibility he was local to the area or known to Donna Lass is a credible argument, and he was either holding Donna Lass at this juncture, needed time to dispose of her body, or possibly needed to remove incriminating evidence from his home or vehicle before the police came knocking. This may have suggested that the responsible moved in the circle of Donna Lass, such as friends and work colleagues, who are inevitably the first people to be questioned in most police investigations. 
The nature of the call was also suggestive of a perpetrator who knew Donna Lass. A friend or work colleague through conversation or private details, would be privy to information about her family, and the fact they lived in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, 1,555 miles away. A phone call in this instance, using a family illness as a ruse, would be of the utmost benefit to the caller, possibly 'buying' the perpetrator plenty of time. The caller it would seem, knew her family did not reside in South Lake Tahoe or nearby, because this would have made the call ineffectual.
Two phone calls were laid, one to her employer and one to her landlord. The first would obviously explain her absence from work after the Labor Day weekend, the second would possibly allay the concerns of her landlord over rent collection. He may have known Donna Lass, but would unlikely have known the exact date her payments were due. The fact he called her landlord at all, is indicative of somebody who was familiar with Donna Lass, unlikely to be known by a random killer or abductor, who just turned up at the Sahara Tahoe Hotel that morning. If the perpetrator was the Zodiac Killer, then his close ties to Donna Lass could be of crucial importance, bearing in mind the widely held belief he was unknown to his victims in the first four confirmed attacks in the Bay Area. If the Zodiac Killer was also known to Cheri Jo Bates, due to the specific targeting of her Volkswagen Beetle, then Riverside and South Lake Tahoe may be more closely linked than ever imagined.  

Picture
​Donna Lass had recently moved into the Monte Verdi apartments on 3893 Pioneer Trail Road, located just a three minute drive from the Sahara Tahoe Hotel. When she first arrived in South Lake Tahoe in June she stayed with Ann and Larry Lowe at 4054 US Highway 50, and was just finding her feet in the new residence when she went missing. Although her 1968 Chevrolet Camaro convertible was discovered outside the Monte Verdi apartment complex in its usual parking spot, it is believed she had not driven it to work on the evening of her disappearance, having walked to work from this previous residence, which was a short walking distance to the Sahara Tahoe Hotel of approximately 8-10 minutes. She had made plans to meet up with her friend Jo Anne Goettsche, intending to travel back to the Monte Verdi Apartments in her vehicle, once her shift at the casino had finished.
The fact she was targeted immediately on her shift change at around 1.50 am is also telling. Had a nurse just vanished from the start or middle of her shift, this would obviously have raised a red flag with the Sahara Tahoe Casino, negating the intention of the abductor, and most certainly rendering the phone call unnecessary and highly suspicious. She had already changed from her nurses uniform into her civilian clothes, as her shift was due to end at 2.00 am, something the perpetrator likely knew.
The last person apparently to see Donna Lass before her disappearance was a Joan Bentley from San Francisco, who stated that Donna appeared in good spirits at approximately 1.40 am. The last entry on her log according to her sister, Mary Pilker, was 
"patient complains of", before the pen trailed off the page. This pen mark is unlikely to have been created by her being physically manhandled from the casino, as it was extremely busy during the Labor Day weekend. More likely, is that somebody approached her nurses station and asked for medical assistance in the car park. Donna Lass may have been writing in her nurses log, when she had her arm tugged in a gesture of 'please help,' or had been in the middle of writing, when she abruptly rushed off to aid the concerned citizen. Either way, her pen trailed down the page. 

Picture
The person who made the phone call was also likely aware Donna Lass had not traveled to work that evening in her 1968 Chevrolet Camaro convertible. Had he contacted the Sahara Tahoe Hotel explaining the family illness, and that she had been called 'out of town', then this would have been negated, had her employer or work colleagues noticed her vehicle sitting idle in the car park over the next few days. A vehicle she would likely have used for her trip to South Dakota.
Was the perpetrator aware of her plans to meet Jo Anne Goettsche at around 2.00 am inside the casino, so acted just before the end of her shift. The subsequent phone call may then have served an extra purpose of allaying the worries of Jo Anne Goettsche, had she informed the casino of her concerns or contacted the police. If the perpetrator knew of Donna Lass' arrangement with her friend, he may very well have spoken to her in the preceding days, further cementing the idea he was known to the young woman.
Six and a half months after her disappearance, the 'Pines' postcard was mailed by Zodiac to the San Francisco Chronicle on March 22nd 1971. But why did the likely killer of Donna Lass wait this long to mail the communication. Did his closeness to Donna Lass play any part?
There could be another answer in the words of 
Police Chief Ray Lauritzen; "We don't know where we're going to begin. There's a four or five foot pack of snow out there and it's still snowing heavily. There's no point to a search at this time. It's unlikely a victim would be uncovered before spring."  
The Zodiac did refer to snow in the 'Pines' card. His exact wording was "around in the snow," pasted at ground level and upside-down, possibly signifying that Donna had been buried, or placed under the snow. The snowfall was extremely heavy that winter, and it was "unlikely a victim would be uncovered before spring." Fitting then, that Zodiac contacted the newspapers on March 22nd 1971, just two days after the beginning of Spring.


DONNA LASS-A MURDER PLOT FOILED?

$
0
0
In several articles we have explored the concept of geographical profiling to narrow down the search area for the likely residence of the Zodiac Killer, using timelines and his own words in an effort to identify the elusive murderer. A forum member of Zodiac Killer Site with the moniker 'Seagull' has been invaluable in this quest, mailing me names and addresses around the Springs Road and Tuolumne Street payphone in Vallejo in 1969. By cross checking these to previous residency in Riverside and other locations using ancestry records, a common thread is hoped to be unearthed. The problem is, it may take months or even years to manually trawl through a sample area radius of just 0.5 miles around the payphone. 
Another common thread that has been explored, is a possible link between Donna Lass and the Zodiac Killer. According to former police officer Harvey Hines "During the time she worked in San Francisco she lived at 4122 Balboa Street with a roommate named Carol Emerich. Emerich was also a nurse. According to the employment records, Lass was working a late night shift in October of 1969 when the San Francisco cab driver, Paul Stine, was killed by the Zodiac."
This, bearing in mind the disappearance and likely murder of Donna Lass only eleven months later, along with the alleged Zodiac 'Pines' card mailed on March 22nd 1971, it is something not to be overlooked. It may be coincidence, but the 'Pines' card does reveal an interesting feature, long believed to be from the hands of a hoaxer because of the victim count not marrying up with known Zodiac correspondence. However, it does in fact fit perfectly into the Zodiac timeline.         
PictureThe Letterman Army Hospital
'Lemonboy', a contributor to this site triggered this article, when he stated "What if Donna lass saw Zodiac as he was walking away from the Stine murder? After that he targets her thinking she might have recognized him. The fact she lived so close to the crime scene seems more than coincidence."
But what if the Zodiac moved in the circle of Donna Lass, knew the young nurse, or even worked alongside her. His confidence in these surroundings was evident after the murder of Paul Stine in Presidio Heights on October 11th 1969, apparent by his detailed account of events in the November 9th 1969 'Bus Bomb' letter. He may have lived in the Vallejo area and worked in San Francisco, hence the copious mailings to the San Francisco Chronicle newspaper. If we could tie this person to Donna Lass through San Francisco and South Lake Tahoe, and possibly Cheri Jo Bates at Riverside, we may inch a little closer. The 'Pines' card may be suspect Zodiac material, but the wording on the postcard does leave a subtle hint that a connection may exist.
It all lies in the wording "Sought Victim 12", considered by some an error on behalf of its sender. But if we examine the victim count of the Zodiac Killer, the past participle of seek, indicated the killer may have been targeting Donna Lass during her residency in San Francisco some four months earlier.

"Sought Victim 12" suggested that the Zodiac Killer at some point in his recent history had trailed victim 12. Bearing in mind the 'Pines' card was supposedly referencing the disappearance and murder of Donna Lass on September 6th 1970, then it isn't a giant leap of faith to believe that the murderer was searching for victim 12 relative to his timeline and the young nurse.
On April 20th 1970 the Zodiac Killer mailed the '13 Symbol' cipher claiming 10 victims. On June 26th 1970 the killer mailed the 'Button' letter and Phillips 66 map claiming 12 victims. His search for victim 12 was clearly over, according to him, therefore it couldn't have been Donna Lass, who was abducted just over two months later. However, she may have been the original target. If she had been earmarked as victim 12, as hinted by the 'Pines' card, his plans were clearly thwarted or sidelined.​      

PictureDonna Ann Lass
Before Zodiac could "seek victim 12" though, he had to secure victim 11, which he wasn't claiming when the 'Dragon' card landed at the offices of the San Francisco Chronicle on April 28th 1970. Donna Lass left her job at the Letterman General Hospital and moved to South Lake Tahoe on June 6th 1970 to begin her new post at the Sahara Tahoe Hotel and Casino. If he had targeted Donna Lass in San Francisco, it would likely have fell somewhere between the dates of April 28th 1970 and June 6th 1970, but was ultimately denied to him by circumstances unknown or her move away from the Bay Area. Even if Zodiac had claimed victim 11 as early as the end of April, then we could be looking for a man who either worked with the young nurse during the month of May, was in her near circle, or had a romantic or unhealthy interest in Donna Lass during this short timeframe.
Friends and colleagues of Donna Lass included Carol Emerich and Jo Anne Goettsche, who visited her on the day she disappeared, and it is these friends, or persons close to them, that may hold the key to the identity of the Zodiac Killer during that crucial month in 1970. When the killer mailed the 'Pines' card on March 22nd 1971, either by accident or design, his mask of anonymity may have slipped even further upon pasting the words "Sought Victim 12," and place him a lot closer to Donna Lass than we care to imagine.   

THE MIKADO CODE?

$
0
0
The Zodiac Killer teased us with his name on more than one occasion, firstly in the July 31st 1969 San Francisco Chronicle letter where he stated "I want you to print this cipher on the front page of your paper. In this cipher is my idenity." He would follow this up with the 'My Name is...' letter on April 20th 1970 and the 'Halloween' card on October 27th 1970 tempting us with his name again; "I feel it in my bones, You ache to know my name, And so I'll clue you in.." 
​It would appear however, this was never to be the case and we are still no nearer to securing the identity of the Zodiac Killer nearly half a century later. It always seemed strange the Zodiac Killer would interpose the Gilbert and Sullivan Mikado into his correspondence, leading researchers to believe he was a fan of the theater, having quoted three acts of The Mikado in the 'Little List' letter of July 26th 1970 and 'Exorcist' letter of January 29th 1974. But there may be an ulterior motive behind this apparent fascination with Gilbert and Sullivan, in that the killer was using the Mikado to reveal his name, and likely through four mailings rather than the accepted two. We will take a closer look at these four correspondences and the speculative links between them, without claiming this is anything more than coincidence. Let us first look at the 'Exorcist' letter.   
PictureClick to enlarge
The first thing to notice is its carefully structured appearance, being divided neatly into four sections of text. The curious thing about the correspondence is Zodiac wrote "Signed, yours truley," as though he was about to offer up his name in the third block of writing. He then recited ​Act II -On a tree by a river from The Mikado. It seemed like Zodiac was wasting our time, plucking out random verses from The Mikado, that is until you read verse three of this particular act. It not only contained a reference to 'name', but pointed us towards 'The My Name is...' cipher, mailed on April 20th 1970. Here is verse three.
Now I feel just as sure as I'm sure that my name
Isn't Willow, titwillow, titwillow,
That 'twas blighted affection that made him exclaim
"Oh, willow, titwillow, titwillow!"
And if you remain callous and obdurate, I
Shall perish as he did, and you will know why,
Though I probably shall not exclaim as I die,

"Oh, willow, titwillow, titwillow!"

Was the Zodiac Killer giving us clues to his identity or name, by leading us back to the '13 Symbol' cipher. This observation on its own is meaningless, so we will travel back in time to the 'Little List' letter mailed on July 26th 1970, the supposed only other correspondence to contain references to The Mikado- in fact two. The first section of the 'Little List' letter pulled lines from  'A more humane Mikado', and continued on to extensively recite Gilbert and Sullivan's Mikado Act One Part 5a  'As some day it may happen', performed by Ko-Ko. In the introductory part of the letter, Zodiac simply boasted about how he would torture his slaves in paradise, but he again did something curious, by selecting just one small section of 'A more humane Mikado,' despite it being ten verses in length. The same as he did in the 'Exorcist' letter. He then continued to paraphrase the entirety of 'As some day it may happen'.
The 'Exorcist' letter, we have shown to have tenuous links to the April 20th 1970 'My Name is...' letter, using verse three of 'Tit-Willow'. So let us look at the small section of text Zodiac selected from 
'A more humane Mikado.'
The 'Little List' letter read "And all billiard players I shall have them play in a darkened dungen cell with crooked cues + Twisted Shoes."  Why does Zodiac select this small portion. Was this also hinting towards the 'My Name is...' cipher.
When we think of billiard players or billiard balls from the standpoint of America, eight-ball comes to mind, and the circled eights on the '13 Symbol' cipher. 
Picture
This is the full verse (right) from 'A more humane Mikado.' It is actually verse eight out of ten, providing us with the numerical link, as did verse three from the 'Exorcist' letter. The Zodiac Killer did state on the 'My Name is...' letter; "PS I hope you have fun trying to figgure out who I killed."​​
There is however another link from 'A more humane Mikado,' to the alphabetical characters on the '13 Symbol' code mailed by Zodiac.
The Zodiac Killer supplied us with eight alphabetical characters, reading from left to right  A, E, N, K, M, N, A and M.
In the diagram below, key sections of 'A more humane Mikado' are highlighted for comparison to the '13 Symbol' cipher. Seven letters have been highlighted in green and yellow. This is where we must take a bold leap of faith, and consider that the Zodiac Killer chose The Mikado by Gilbert and Sullivan because it simply contained his name, Kim. Nothing more theatrical than that. 

The green highlighted sections on 'A more humane Mikado' in reverse, read KIMNAM. If we believe therefore, that the middle eight represents the letter I on the '13 Symbol' cipher, it reads forward KIMNAM, exactly the same. The remaining letters of the cipher AEN are shown highlighted in yellow. Every letter on the '13 Symbol' cipher is contained within this section of seven letters. 
​The three eights encapsulated his identity, just like the three eights at the foot of the '340' character cipher mailed on November 8th 1969: The Mathematics of the 13 Symbol Cipher. Who said the Magic 8 ball was just for telling fortunes! Additionally, Mikado can be formed using the alphabetical characters on the 20th line of the '340' cipher.
The Zodiac was keen to share with us what he had in store for his slaves in paradise:
"This is the Zodiac speaking. Being that you will not wear some nice buttons, how about wearing some nasty buttons. Or any kind of buttons that you can think up. If you do not wear any type of buttons, I shall (on top of everything else) torture all 13 of my slaves that I have waiting for me in Paradice. Some I shall tie over ant hills and watch them scream + twich and squirm. Others shall have pine splinters driven under their nails + then burned. Others shall be placed in cages + fed salt beef untill they are gorged then I shall listen to their pleass for water and I shall laugh at them. Others will hang by their thumbs + burn in the sun then I will rub them down with deep heat to warm them up. Others I shall skin them alive + let them run around screaming. And all billiard players I shall have them play in a darkened dungen cell with crooked cues + Twisted Shoes. Yes I shall have great fun inflicting the most delicious of pain to my slaves."
The talk of slaves, paradise, pine splinters, dungeons and hanging his 'prisoners' by the thumbs, catapulted me to the 'Halloween' card mailed on October 27th 1970, and the last Mikado installment. The Zodiac Killer placed some wording around the knothole in the tree:"peek a boo you are doomed." Bearing in mind that The Mikado opened to the paying public on March 14th 1885, and was hugely successful, running for 672 performances at the Savoy Theatre in London, a British connection had to be sought. The British term for peek-a-boo is peep-bo, and peep-bo is a character in The Mikado.      

CHERI JO BATES: RE-EVALUATING THE CRIME SCENE

$
0
0
Here we will take a fresh look at the Cheri Jo Bates murder in Riverside on October 30th 1966, using the 'Confession' letter, excerpts from Robert Graysmith's book, details from police, and earwitnesses to pinpoint the location of Cheri Jo Bates' Volkswagen Beetle and the vehicle of her assailant.
The 'Inside Detective' Magazine from January 1969 stated "At the murder scene, drops of dried blood leading from the body to Terracina Street indicated to the detective that the murderer had walked back to the street following the slaying." This indicated the killer was walking back to his vehicle, parked on Terracina Drive. But which way did he head, east or west. The Riverside City College library was situated approximately 75- 80 yards (240 feet) east of the alleyway, where the slain girl was discovered. There are, as always, conflicting versions of the same event. The 'Inside Detective' Magazine stated "The Riverside Sheriff's Department picked up the broadcast. Minutes later, Sheriff's Detective Sergeant Jack Reid and Detective Jack Elms discovered the little car. It was parked at the curb in front of the college library about 75 feet (25 yards) from the entrance of the roadway where the girl's body was found."  
Robert Graysmith, in his book Zodiac. stated "He probably came up and offered help, offered her a lift in his car. Then he got her to go down the unlit gravel road to the parking lot, about 75 yards east of her car."
The Riverside Police Department memorandum stated "She returned to her vehicle, which was parked on a city street a short distance from the library, placed her books in the vehicle, and attempted to start her vehicle, The vehicle had been tampered with so it would not start. This was evidently done by the suspect to keep the victim near her vehicle, so the suspect could make his approach. Our victim then left her vehicle, accompanied by the suspect, and walked approximately 200 feet (67 yards) into a dirt driveway between two houses."
Below I have interpreted the statements. One vehicle is placed between 67-75 yards west of the alleyway (which was "about 75 yards east of her car"). The second interpretation places the vehicle "in front of the college library" about 25 yards west of the alleyway. These appear the two options.  
Next we will examine the 'Confession letter' wording to pinpoint the location of the assailant/s vehicle, along with the true location of Cheri Jo Bates' Volkswagen Beetle. The 'Confession' letter stated "Then I waited for her in the library and followed her out after about two minutes. The battery must have been about dead by then. I offered to help. She was then very willing to talk to me. I told her that my car was down the street and I would give her a lift home. When we were away from the library walking, I said it was about time. She asked me "about time for what." I said it was about time for her to die."
If the author of the 'Confession' letter was honest in his directional movements that night, then his choice of words "when we were away from the library walking," seems to suggest he was walking away from the library, towards the alleyway and his vehicle, having already offered Cheri Jo Bates help in fixing her Volkswagen Beetle. This indicated that Cheri Jo Bates' vehicle was parked somewhere close to the library, and going by the above options, 25 yards east of the alleyway.
​If her disabled Volkswagen Beetle was parked 70 yards west of the alleyway, then his statement in the 'Confession' letter of "When we were away from the library walking, I said it was about time. She asked me "about time for what." I said it was about time for her to die," makes it appear he is heading in the wrong direction. Considering the relative positions of the Volkswagen Beetle (70 yards west) and the alleyway in this instance, he would have been walking towards the library, not away from the library.
However, the Volkswagen Beetle being parked 25 yards east of the alleyway flies in the face of the Riverside Police Department memorandum, which indicated her vehicle was parked 200 feet (67 yards) from the alleyway. The Riverside Police Department memorandum and Robert Graysmith's book appear to corroborate one another in terms of distance from the alleyway.   
Picture
But what if the Volkswagen Beetle was parked 67-75 yards east of the alleyway, instead of 75 yards west, as Robert Graysmith stated in his book. This would literally place the Volkswagen Beetle very close to the library doors, using the measurement capabilities of Google maps, and corroborate the Riverside Police Department memorandum, which stated "her vehicle was parked on a city street a short distance from the library." This also tallies with the 'Inside Detective' Magazine, in which police said her Volkswagen Beetle "was parked at the curb in front of the college library." They did however, go on to state her vehicle was 75 feet from the alleyway, not 75 yards. But it's my guess they made a mistake or were misquoted.  
One wouldn't have imagined parking spaces that difficult to find on a Sunday evening, particularly bearing in mind Cheri Jo Bates had arrived at the library around opening time, before many of the other 65 attendees. This may also challenge the notion of her parking her vehicle 150 yards (450 feet) from the library entrance, along Terracina Drive, leaving her an unnecessary distance to walk. This revamped assessment now places her vehicle approximately 75 yards east of the alleyway, very close to the library, and "parked at the curb in front of the college library." Or "parked on a city street a short distance from the library."  Not on the west side of the alleyway as originally believed. 
But where was the assailant's vehicle parked? In the 'Confession' letter the author stated he "waited for her in the library and followed her out after about two minutes." We know that Cheri Jo Bates was not murdered until approximately 10.30 pm, so much of what the 'Confession' letter depicts is false, however his wording can still give us a clue to the location of where his vehicle was parked. It is extremely likely the killer either trailed Cheri Jo Bates to the library that evening, or pulled up near to the library on the expectation of her arrival, maintaining a visual on the entrance. Regardless of what time she entered the library, or where she went that evening, the assailant would have parked somewhere on Terracina Drive to facilitate his plan, hence the wording on the 'Confession' letter: "I told her that my car was down the street and I would give her a lift home." and "when we were away from the library walking." This indicated his vehicle was parked west of the library entrance, towards the alleyway. 

Picture
He clearly didn't want to park his vehicle by the Riverside City College library steps, as this would risk his vehicle being associated with the Volkswagen Beetle of Cheri Jo Bates. The wording on the 'Confession' letter of his vehicle "down the street," to lure her towards the alleyway, would suggest his vehicle was somewhere close to the alleyway. This would facilitate a speedy exit from the alleyway after the knife attack on Cheri Jo Bates, which would inevitably have left him with blood on his clothes. This was backed up by earwitnesses close to the alleyway, who likely heard the perpetrator's vehicle pulling away from the scene.
In the Robert Graysmith book it stated "A neighbor heard an 'awful scream' between 10.15 and 10.45 pm, and then about two minutes of silence, and finally the sound of an old car starting up." 
The neighbor's claim is backed up by the latter part of the 'Confession' letter: "She died hard. She squirmed and shook as I choked her, and her lips twitched. She let out a scream once and I kicked her head to shut her up. I plunged the knife into her and it broke. I then finished the job by cutting her throat." 
After Cheri Jo Bates screamed, according to the author, he kicked her and then used the knife twice to finally kill her. Taking this at less than 30 seconds, and assuming the killer and starting car are connected, what did the killer do for the remaining 90 odd seconds. If his vehicle was relatively close by (30 seconds journey)- so that the neighbor was able to hear it starting up, then we are probably looking for an unaccounted minute of time. Was this time used in searching for the Timex watch, wrenched off his wrist in the struggle with Cheri Jo Bates. 
Based on everything learned, the Volkswagen Beetle of Cheri Jo Bates was likely parked very close to the library annex, 75 yards east, or thereabouts from the ill fated alleyway. The assailant's vehicle was also parked on Terracina Drive, within earshot of the alleyway, on either the east or west side. "At the murder scene, drops of dried blood leading from the body to Terracina Street indicated to the detective that the murderer had walked back to the street following the slaying."
But only a matter of yards from the alleyway, before driving away.    

FOOTNOTE: Newspaper article excerpt - Death on a Driveway, A life that ended too soon.  
"Some of her friends were at the library between 7 and 9 pm, but none can recall seeing Cheri. She had been there, however, because three books stamped that day were found in the front seat of her yellow-green Volkswagen found parked on Terracina, near the annex. Someone else was there too. Someone who police believe knew Cheri- knew her well enough to recognize her car. The distributor had been tampered with and there was evidence that the man had been in the car with her. The keys were still in the ignition when the car was found the next day. Both windows had been rolled down and the right door was ajar."  

CHERI JO BATES: RE-EVALUATING THE CRIME SCENE [PART TWO]

$
0
0
Here we will take an even deeper look into the events of October 30th 1966, partially using the excellent timeline of Ray Grant from his book 'Zodiac Killer Solved.' We may disagree on certain aspects of the crime, but he makes extremely interesting observations regarding the movements of Cheri Jo Bates that evening, and the fact that the young woman would never have willingly left her prized Volkswagen Beetle in the state it was found the following morning. 
We can agree that Cheri Jo Bates left her 4195 Via San Jose residence at approximately 5.05 pm. The next important sighting was from a Mexican-American student, who later stated that "he knew Cheri Jo Bates and had noticed her in the library the night in question. He said he saw the girl "writing something with a ball point pen" in her blue spiral school notebook. The boy told us he was outside about 5.30 pm, waiting for the library to open at 6, and it was then he saw the girl." This statement can be interpreted in two ways. He either saw the girl at 5.30 pm or 6.00 pm. But on this occasion we will opt for around 5.30 pm. for reasons explained in 'Zodiac Killer Solved,' while adding a further component from the 'Inside Detective' Magazine.
​The journey time from her residence to Terracina Drive, where her vehicle was ultimately found 'abandoned,' is a journey time of about 12-15 minutes. She parked her vehicle 30 yards east of the library annex, as explained in the previous article, on the right hand side of the road. The time now is 5.20 pm. She walked the short distance to the library, where the Mexican-American student noticed Cheri Jo Bates "about 5.30 pm." It was likely a few minutes before, because as Ray Grant pointed out, she would eventually notice she wasn't in possession of her bibliography and ventured off to place a payphone call to her co-worker Donna at the Riverside National Bank at 5.30 pm, who said she hadn't seen the bibliography. This call probably lasted for approximately 5 minutes, because the next sighting of Cheri Jo Bates was at 5.40 pm, when she returned back to her vehicle by the library. This eyewitness was not 100% sure of the girl's identity, but there is a high probability it was Cheri Jo Bates, as she was returning to her vehicle, to make the journey back home to retrieve her bibliography.                
Picture
This is where the 'Inside Detective' Magazine comes in handy. It stated "The participants in the reenactment at the detectives' request, wore the same clothing and sat in the same seats that they had occupied the Sunday night of the murder. They were also asked to park their cars in the same places they had on the night of October 30. It had been determined that Cheri Jo (or a girl resembling her and in similar clothes) had arrived at the library about 5.40 pm and waited for about 20 minutes for the doors to be opened. The girl apparently entered the library as soon as the doors were opened at 6.00 pm, and checked out the books she had come for." This seemingly near corroborates everything before it- the sighting of the Mexican-American student just before 5.30 pm, the phone call to Donna at 5.30 pm, and her return to the library at 5.40 pm. There is one big problem however, pointed out by Ray Grant in 'Zodiac Killer Solved.'
Cheri Jo Bates was spotted by two eyewitnesses (a March Air Force Base man and a friend of Cheri's driving on Magnolia Avenue) that evening, arriving toward Terracina Drive at 6.10-6.15 pm. How could she be arriving at the college at 6.15 pm, when supposedly she was entering the library at 6.00 pm, having earlier arrived at the college library around 5.20 pm. Had she arrived at the college twice, then she must have returned home at some point to search for her bibliography. 
If we take the 5.40 pm eyewitness sighting as Cheri Jo Bates, this may corroborate her Volkswagen Beetle parked only 90 feet east of the library entrance. She was returning from the payphone, heading west to east, toward the library entrance, to consider a journey back home. Had her vehicle been parked 360 feet west of the library or 75 yards west of the alleyway, as asserted by Robert Graysmith, then this eyewitness would not have assumed Cheri Jo Bates was "arriving at the library at 5.40 pm." The magazine stated that apparently she entered the library at 6.00 pm, and had waited 20 minutes from arriving. It is highly likely this is supposition on behalf of the investigators, based upon the 5.40 pm sighting. As Ray Grant suggested, Cheri Jo Bates likely entered her vehicle at 5.40 pm or thereabouts, and drove the 24 minute journey to and from her residence to collect her bibliography. Allowing for the turnaround and locating her bibliography, 30 minutes is a reasonable estimate, placing her arriving back on Terracina Drive at 6.10 pm, where she was spotted by both the March Air Force Base man and her friend.

Picture
In one newspaper article it stated, "Some of her friends were at the library between 7 and 9 pm, but none can recall seeing Cheri. She had been there, however, because three books stamped that day were found in the front seat of her yellow-green Volkswagen found parked on Terracina, near the annex. Someone else was there too. Someone who police believe knew Cheri- knew her well enough to recognize her car. The distributor had been tampered with and there was evidence that the man had been in the car with her. The keys were still in the ignition when the car was found the next day. Both windows had been rolled down and the right door was ajar." 
The 'Inside Detective' Magazine added that "the keys were in the ignition, but the car had been disabled and would not start. It was found that the distributor coil and condenser had been ripped out. Greasy finger and palm prints were discovered on the door of the car. Two school books and a notepad were found in the front seat." 
Ray Grant believes that Cheri Jo Bates was abducted from her Volkswagen Beetle shortly after arriving at the library at 6.10-6.15 pm, indicating she never entered the library that night. Had the Mexican-American student only spotted Cheri Jo Bates at "about 5.30 pm" outside the library, then no eyewitnesses at all that night had recalled Cheri Jo Bates inside the library. Ray Grant believes it wasn't Cheri Jo Bates that checked out the library books, but the perpetrators of the crime.
We may disagree on the events from 6.15 pm onward, but an abduction cannot be ruled out, as the young woman was 'missing' for just over 4 hours, until screams were heard coming from the alleyway, where Cheri Jo Bates would ultimately be found by groundskeeper Cleophus Martin the following morning.
She was almost certainly forcibly removed from her vehicle, particularly so, if only one assailant approached her vehicle that evening or night. If, as the 'Confession' letter intimated, she walked willingly away from her vehicle, then it is extremely unlikely a conscientious woman, who prided her Volkswagen Beetle, would leave the keys in the ignition, both windows rolled down and the doors unlocked, with one possibly ajar. The state of her vehicle clearly indicated she was under duress at this point.​  

Picture
We have to emphasize the fact that both her vehicle windows were rolled down. 'In October 1966 the average high temperature in Riverside, CA was 80.7°F, and this was 0.2°F cooler than the average of 80.9°F. The hottest day in October 1966 was 31 October when the temperature reached 91.9°F. Overnight the average temperature in October is 51.8°F.'
Had Cheri Jo Bates' vehicle been sitting idle for an extended period of time in front of her 4195 Via San Jose residence, earlier that day, then the temperature inside her Volkswagen Beetle would have been stifling. This certainly would have necessitated her rolling down both windows before her journey. On either journey, it's highly likely one would roll down both windows to circulate the air in temperatures exceeding 80 degrees Fahrenheit. This fact alone may support her abduction or forcible removal from her vehicle as she parked up on Terracina Drive, before she had chance to roll up the windows and exit the vehicle. It may also explain the keys still in the ignition and the doors unlocked, with one not fully closed, especially if more than one assailant was involved. This however, is where the library books come into play in Ray Grant's diversion theory, in 'Zodiac Killer Solved'. It is an extremely interesting read. 
If on the other hand she was forcibly removed, let's say under gunpoint or knife, shortly before 10.30 pm, when she arrived back from her 'missing' 4 hours, and then coerced into the alleyway, before being murdered, we have to ask ourselves the question. Would Cheri Jo Bates have arrived back at her vehicle at approximately 10.25 pm at night and rolled down both windows of her vehicle, before attempting to drive away. Or had she rolled down the passenger side window specifically, to converse with somebody on the sidewalk, who was offering her assistance with the stricken vehicle. Were the unlocked doors, greasy fingerprints and "evidence that the man had been in the car with her," a sign that she initially felt comfortable with the good Samaritan, or that it was somebody she knew.
All the evidence suggests that Cheri Jo Bates was forced from her vehicle that night, but was it around 6.15-6.20 pm, or shortly before 10.30 pm. Or is there another scenario, that may yet shed light on the events of October 30th 1966. 

http://www.zodiacciphers.com/zodiac-news/cheri-jo-bates-re-evaluating-the-crime-scene
 
Zodiac Killer Solved by Ray Grant.  

CRIMINOLOGY PODCAST SERIES

$
0
0
Picture
Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford have now completed eight episodes of their excellent podcast series, covering all the confirmed crimes and communications of the Zodiac Killer, as well as some of the possible links to the Bay Area murderer. The podcast series is an excellent way to introduce yourself to the Zodiac case in double quick time, without having to scour numerous websites and forums. Below are the eight individual episodes listed chronologically, as well as the main Criminology homepage
​Episode 1- A Killer Strikes 
​Episode 2- A Killer Deciphered
Episode 3- A Killer Changes His MO
Episode 4- A Killer Takes Credit 
Episode 5- The Riverside Connection
Episode 6- Zodiac's Riverside Roots Examined  
​Episode 7- Looking In Lake Tahoe
Episode 8- A Killer's Epilogue  

But this podcast series is far from over. There are still more Zodiac Killer episodes to come, which will be added in due course.
The Criminology series, hosted by Stitcher, will then move on to cover other well known criminal investigations.
Here is Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford's introduction to the show:"Criminology is a true crime podcast that takes a deep dive into some of the most famous cases in the annals of crime. Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Morford will give you every details of these infamous crimes. Each season is a new case, told over 8-10 episodes."
These podcasts are also available on iTunes and Google Play, the links to which can be found on Facebook and Twitter below.
Twitter.com/@CriminologyPod and Facebook.com/CriminologyPodcast.
These pages can also be used to leave your feedback on the series so far, as well as contribute to the infamous cases covered.  

THE RIVERSIDE PROPHECY

$
0
0
The 'Confession' letter purportedly typed by the hand of Cheri Jo Bates' murderer delivered a sense of foreboding: "She is not the first and she will not be the last. I lay awake nights thinking about my next victim. Maybe she will be the beautiful blond that babysits near the little store and walks down the dark alley each evening about seven. Or maybe she will be the shapely blue eyed brownett that said no when I asked her for a date in high school. But maybe it will not be either....Yes I did make that call to you. It was just a warning. Beware...I am stalking your girls now."  
This was equally true of the Riverside Desktop Poem, discovered by a Janitor at Riverside City College in the December of 1966, after the murder of Cheri Jo Bates, and after the 'Confession' letter, but in all probability was written before the October 30th 1966 murder. It gave a chilling prelude to what may transpire, what may be denied, but ultimately the threat of more to come: "Just wait till next time. rh." 
If the Desktop Poem was written in the October of 1966 by the same mind who typed the 'Confession' letter, then it could be argued it was the prelude to the murder of Cheri Jo Bates, and equally argued as the first correspondence of the Zodiac Killer, if you believe a connection exists between the Bay Area and Riverside.    
PictureClick to enlarge
The Zodiac Killer often ended his communications with an unbridled mockery of police, giving a running total of victims so far. He would often compliment this in correspondence, such as the November 9th 1969 'Bus Bomb' letter, stating "up to the end of Oct I have killed 7 people." In the November 8th 'Dripping Pen' card he added the months of his alleged attacks, stating "Des, July, Aug, Sept, Oct = 7."  On March 13th 1971 the Zodiac Killer referenced his exploits in Riverside by 'complimenting' the police on connecting the murder of Cheri Jo Bates to him: "I do have to give them credit for stumbling across my riverside activity, but they are only finding the easy ones."
Could the initials rh be offering us something similar. The author of the Riverside Desktop Poem warned us of a "next time," then gave us the initials. Could the author have instructed us on the time and place of his next murder, much like the unconfirmed 'Albany' letter mailed on 
August 1st 1973.
"Just wait till next time. riverside, halloween." The author was giving us the area of the crime and the exact date. The Riverside Desktop Poem was the ode to murder, the 'Confession' letter was its completion. The murder was believed to have taken place at approximately 10.30 pm on October 30th 1966, the day before Halloween. However, if we believe the author of the 'Confession' letter, then his original intention may have been the abduction of Cheri Jo Bates in his vehicle, before things unexpectedly changed course. He may have planned the murder of the young woman on October 31st 1966, the day she was ultimately discovered by groundskeeper Cleophus Martin.    

Picture
In the aftermath of the Cheri Jo Bates murder the police made appeals to the public to be on the lookout for the murder weapon, described as a small knife: "An unrelenting search had been in progress for the murder weapon, and that Tuesday detectives used a metal detector (see right) in shrubbery adjacent to the murder scene in an effort to find the knife used by the slayer. Captain Cross revealed to the news media that the autopsy showed that the murder weapon was probably a pocket knife with a 3 inch blade or less. The broadcast and published information about the knife caused the police switchboard to be flooded with calls reporting knives of similar description being found all over the city of Riverside."  
Was one of those callers the murderer, who did state in the 'Confession' letter "Yes, I did make that call to you." 
How many of these calls were followed up is hard to determine, but curiously on November 14th 1966, one day after the highly publicized library reconstruction, the police did get a call from a Riverside City College gardener: "That he had unearthed a hunting knife with his rake. The knife had apparently been buried near the murder scene. Detectives hurried to the campus and turned over the knife to the homicide detail. However, examination failed to show any evidence of dried blood on the knife blade. Also, its width did not compare with the incisions made by the stab wounds."
Did the murderer of Cheri Jo Bates plant the hunting knife and make a call to police, which ultimately got lost in the myriad of calls flooding the switchboard, and consequently was not followed through. Or did the killer make contact with the Riverside City College gardener to volunteer this information, while viewing the unfolding police presence from a distance. 
The police had thoroughly searched the crime scene with metal detectors in the days after the murder, so it seems likely the knife was planted subsequent to their search by either the perpetrator, or a misguided prankster. The planting of a larger hunting knife near the murder scene may have been another foreboding message by the killer, that "It was just a warning. Beware...I am stalking your girls now." Stalking them with a larger and more deadly knife. After all, he did claim that he "plunged the knife into her and it broke."

Picture
For many people, Cheri Jo Bates checked out her own library books. This being the case, we have approximately four hours in which her whereabouts are unexplained. Had she gone somewhere willingly, it is highly likely she traveled there by foot, having left her vehicle parked on Terracina Drive at about 6.15 pm.
Does this center the investigation close to the college campus?
The author of the 'Confession' letter was fond of referring to that "alley," when he stated "Maybe she will be the beautiful blond that babysits near the little store and walks down the dark alley each evening about seven" and "it just might save that girl in the alley." Was he referring to the alleyway in which Cheri Jo Bates was murdered, or some other alley in the vicinity of the Riverside City College campus. Somewhere he could monitor the comings and goings of young attractive women.
If he was able to go unnoticed, without drawing suspicion to himself around the college campus the evening of October 30th 1966, had composed the Desktop Poem earlier that month, and had subsequently planted the knife near the crime scene, was this indicative of somebody who worked at, or frequented the college on a regular basis. Somebody who could travel within the confines of Riverside City College unchallenged and blend into the background. 
The Timex watch discovered ten feet from the body of Cheri Jo Bates, apparently ripped off the wrist of the killer in the struggle, had white paint specks on its face. The Riverside City College was undergoing renovation at this point in time, so is this another small pointer. The attack on Cheri Jo Bates was fairly prolonged, evident by the wounds sustained by the young woman, inflicted on her in an alleyway bordered by two vacant properties. Is this yet further indication of prior knowledge to college affairs, that the killer was prepared to attack Cheri Jo Bates here, knowing that nobody resided within these properties. This again, reinforcing the idea that the murderer either worked within the college campus, or frequented it regularly. He would seemingly stick around until at least April 30th 1967, when three more virtually simultaneous communications were received from the alleged murderer, in similar fashion to the beginning of the Zodiac correspondence, just over two years later.   

LAKE BERRYESSA- A KILLER'S TIMELINE

$
0
0
The following will re-examine the timeline of the Lake Berryessa attack on September 27th 1969, placing the Zodiac Killer's vehicle approximately 1.1 to 1.2 miles from the crime scene during the brutal stabbing of Bryan Hartnell and Cecelia Shepard. 
Two other sets of eyewitnesses, Dr Rayfield and his son, and the three young women, both may have seen the killer that day, possibly from the near identical location. This location being 0.8 miles from the 1956 White Volkswagen Karmann Ghia of Bryan Hartnell.
To get an overview of the crime scene we must use details given in the police report, and in addition to this, use the Zodiac Killer's phone call to Dave Slaight to pinpoint the likely location of his vehicle. These are some of the crucial measurements:
The Zodiac Killer stated in the phone call to police, "I want to report a murder, no, a double murder. They are two miles north of Park Headquarters. They were in a white Volkswagen Karmann Ghia. I'm the one that did it".  They were in fact 0.7 miles north of Park Headquarters.
The three young women who potentially saw Zodiac, "parked their vehicle at a location two miles north of the A & W Root Beer stand on Knoxville Road." The Sugar Loaf Park A & W was situated at 5100 Knoxville Road.
The second set of eyewitnesses saw the Zodiac later that day: "Dr Rayfield and his son stated that they did not notice a vehicle in the area of their vehicle and only this subject at a distance of about 100 yards. This location was approximately 8/10ths of a mile from the scene of the victim's vehicle. There are four coves of water between the scene of the crime and the area where the doctor saw the subject."  
Using these statements we can now create the relative positions of everybody that day, using the measurement tools on Google Maps.   
The first thing to be noticed using these approximate measurements, is that the position of Dr Rayfield & his son would be at the very same location as the three young women, or at the very least, in the same vicinity. The Zodiac Killer's vehicle would have been relocated 0.3-0.4 miles north of the three young women, after he had 'stalked' them from the hillside.
The police report stated that "at 3.30 pm she and her two girlfriends parked their vehicle at a location two miles north of the A & W Root Beer stand on Knoxville Road." They then walked to the beach. "After approximately one-half hour had passed, they observed what appeared to be the same subject standing with 40 or 50 feet of them, apparently observing them. The subject hung around the area for approximately 45 minutes and then the girls observed him walk up the hill." Allowing 10 minutes for the girls to get their belongings from their vehicle and walk to the beach, the total time passed, would have the man walking up the hill at around 4.55 pm.
One page later in the police report, it stated "The three girls left the area about 4.30 pm and the subjects vehicle was gone."  This discrepancy is not crucial to the remaining timeline, so we will estimate the time the man left at 4.55 pm, with the girls shortly after.
If the Zodiac Killer was preparing an attack on the three girls, he certainly had second thoughts and departed the scene, not unlike his attack at Blue Rock Springs on July 4th 1969, and his switch of intersections at Presidio Heights on October 11th 1969. In both of these examples he was not to be denied, and continued on with his murderous intentions. There may be good reason to believe he had the very same intentions here. The reason being:   
PictureCecelia Shepard
"Dr Rayfield stated that about 6.30 pm the previous evening, he and his son had parked their car north of Park Headquarters in the general area of the crime scene. They stated they went down towards the beach area when David noticed a white male adult subject walking in the area, described as about 5'10", heavy build, wearing dark trousers, a dark shirt with red in it, long sleeves." 
The time they reached the beach and then noticed the man, was likely closer to 6.45-6.50 pm. There is a very good chance that the individual they saw that evening was the Zodiac Killer, and the dark shirt he was wearing "with red in it," was likely the blood of Bryan Hartnell and Cecelia Shepard. The Zodiac Killer was returning to his vehicle from the crime scene 0.8 miles south. The killer was effectively traveling from south to north, and likely had the pass the location of Dr Rayfield and his son to reach his vehicle. 
We have established that this is virtually the same location the three girls were present earlier that afternoon. 
Therefore, when the three sunbathing girls saw the man leave up the hill at approximately 4.55 pm, it could be argued he drove northwards, just beyond this location, which is why he had to pass this area after the brutal double stabbing of the young couple. 
The journey time on foot from the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia (6:30 pm) to the location of Dr Rayfield and son, is approximately 20 minutes along the hillside, This ties in with the estimated time of the David Rayfield sighting, given earlier as 6.50 pm.
But why did the Zodiac Killer leave the scene of the three girls and park a short distance north of their location?
This cannot be fully established, but he may have had second thoughts about murdering the three girls with his vehicle in such close proximity to the scene. There is every chance he left with the full intention of returning 15 minutes later, with a 'buffer zone' in place. The girls however, had left shortly after him, and his murderous plot was foiled.
I have made a calculated guess on the position of the Zodiac Killer's vehicle that afternoon and evening, based on his possible movements after leaving the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia, the fact an off-road parking area is present at that position on Google Maps (and maybe 1969), and the phone call he made from 1231 Main Street, which we will return to later.    

Picture
The man would have walked back to the girls location at around 5.10 pm (4.55 pm + 15 minutes). He then had to walk back down the hill to approach the girls for a second time. However, they had left the area and returned home, leaving the Zodiac Killer searching the area in vain, and possibly for alternative victims. The search, and travel time up and down the hill, we shall guesstimate at 30 minutes, taking the time to 5.40 pm. The Zodiac Killer then travels 0.8 miles south along the hillside, searching for potential targets along the way. He happens upon the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia at 6.00 pm (0.8 miles walking time of 20 minutes). This allows the killer 30 minutes to approach Bryan Hartnell and Cecelia Shepard, enter into brief dialogue, secure them, and begin his deadly attack, before returning up the hill to 'sign' the car door with 6:30 pm.
His journey time back to his vehicle, past the Rayfield's, takes roughly 25-30 minutes, which has him entering his vehicle at approximately 6.55-7.00 pm for the 28 mile return journey towards the Napa payphone. Traveling at near 40 mph, he would have arrived at the 1231 Main Street, Napa payphone circa 7.35-7.40 pm, the exact time the call was logged by police dispatcher Dave Slaight. 
The phone call contained the ominous message "I want to report a murder, no, a double murder. They are two miles north of Park Headquarters. They were in a white Volkswagen Karmann Ghia. I'm the one that did it." However, Park Headquarters was 0.7 miles from the crime scene, not 2 miles as he claimed. So how could the killer make such a big error, particularly if he was familiar with the area. It is perfectly conceivable he simply made a basic mistake. His vehicle was likely parked about 2 miles from Park Headquarters as the crow flies.
Deputy Ray Land and Sergeant David Collins were dispatched directly to the crime scene from St Helena and Napa respectively.  Sgt David Collins spoke on the documentary 'This is the Zodiac Speaking' "It took us a half hour from Napa and/or St Helena to arrive at the location. And we later found out of course that crime had occurred at least half an hour before we were notified." They were notified at 7.10 pm, so arrived en scene at approximately 7.40 pm. 
The Zodiac Killer would have exited the Berryessa-Knoxville Road literally minutes before they entered it.


LAKE BERRYESSA- A KILLER'S TIMELINE [PART TWO]

$
0
0
In the previous article we estimated that the Zodiac Killer arrived at the location of Bryan Hartnell's 1956 White Karmann Ghia at approximately 6.00 pm. Here we shall reverse the timeline of Ronald Fong, the man who noticed the stricken couple from his boat on Lake Berryessa and set off for help at the Rancho Monticello Resort, and hopefully attempt to verify or negate this finding. It may also answer the question of whether the 6:30 written on Bryan Hartnell's vehicle was the time of the attack or the time of writing. Here are some key statements to consider.
#1. On page 6 of the police report it read "White stated at approximately 18.55 hours 9/27/69 he was on routine patrol around the Lake Berryessa area when he received a call from Park Headquarters to proceed to the Rancho Monticello Resort where a person was reporting a possible stabbing. Ronald Fong advised him that he had seen a male and a female victim on the beach area south of Rancho Monticello Resort, hollering that they had been stabbed." link
#2.
Bryan Hartnell interview: "There was a boat kept circling around out there in the lake and we started yelling at it and finally it came within about 100 yards of the shore and turned off its motor and stayed there watching us for about 15 minutes." link
#3. 
"I heard this screaming," said Fong, who has relocated to Washington state but was back in San Francisco last week visiting his family. "I used binoculars to see what was going on. He wanted me to go help him. But I had my 9-year-old son. ... I was close to the boathouse, so I went and told the park rangers." link
#4. "Victim stated he thought suspect had been with the couple for approximately 15 minutes from time of observing suspect until suspect departed." link 

The Rancho Monticello Resort is 3.7 miles by road from the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia, 3.2 miles as the crow flies. By boat from the area of the crime scene to dock at the Rancho Monticello Resort is also approximately 3.7 miles.
We shall use these pieces of information to calculate the time of the attack, first of all using the shortest timeline.  
Picture
What we don't know is the speed that Ronald Fong traveled in his boat, so we will estimate this to begin with, at 10.mph.
Sergeant William White received a call from Park Headquarters regarding the attack and proceeded to the Rancho Monticello Resort at 6.55 pm. Because this time is approximated, we will take 6.55 pm as the time Ronald Fong reported the stabbing at the Rancho Monticello Resort, and assume it was transferred through fairly quickly. 
The journey time of Ronald Fong at an estimated 10 mph is 22.2 minutes (22 approx). After docking his boat he traveled by foot to the Rancho Monticello Resort, and allocating little time to the delay in transferring the call to Sergeant William White, this is estimated at 6 minutes. So far, a minimum of 28 minutes has elapsed since Ronald Fong departed the crime scene.
Bryan Hartnell stated that after the attack Ronald Fong had "stayed there watching us for about 15 minutes." This time may have appeared longer than it actually was, but it will remain untouched, because Bryan Hartnell certainly wouldn't have started shouting for help immediately with the Zodiac Killer nearby. This delay in calling for help will be incorporated into the 15 minutes. Keeping these timelines as tight as possible will compensate for the speed of Ronald Fong's boat, had it traveled slightly quicker.
Adding the 15 minutes to the 28 minutes already elapsed, we have 43 minutes to deduct from 6.55 pm (18.55 pm), to tell us when the Zodiac Killer finished his attack on the young couple. This would have been 6.12 pm.
Now let us ramp up the speed of the boat to 20 mph. This would cut his journey time in half, to 11 minutes. Giving us a total time elapsed of 32 minutes, placing the end of the attack at 6.23 pm. Traveling at an unlikely 30 mph, the end of the attack would be 6.27 pm. But having kept the timeline as tight as possible, to allow the 10 mph boat speed, the end of the attack was more likely around 6.12-6.17 pm.
On page 6 of the police report it continued "Sergeant William White stated he proceeded to the Rancho Monticello Resort where a person was reporting a stabbing. Ranger Sgt White, accompanied by Archie White, Mrs Elizabeth White and Ronald Fong, proceeded to the beach area via speedboat owned by Archie White. When they arrived on the beach they observed a young female lying on the ground with what appeared to be numerous stab wounds. White stated he immediately radioed in and had Park Headquarters radio the Sheriff's Office to dispatch an ambulance and deputy."  
Deputy Ray Land and Sergeant David Collins were dispatched directly to the crime scene from St Helena and Napa respectively. Sgt David Collins spoke on the documentary 'This is the Zodiac Speaking' "It took us a half hour from Napa and/or St Helena to arrive at the location. And we later found out of course that crime had occurred at least half an hour before we were notified." They were notified at approximately 7.10 pm, which by their statement above would place the crime at around 6.10 pm.
Allowing Sergeant William White 8 minutes from being radioed at 6.55 pm to entering the speedboat and 1 minute to reaching Cecelia Shepard once they arrived at the crime scene and contacting Park Headquarters, who in turn contacted the Sheriff's Office, this affords 6 minutes for the speedboat journey. Or 7 minutes if we tighten the timeline. The speedboat was therefore traveling approximately 30-37 mph. This is the reason they took Archie White's speedboat- it likely accommodated four people and could travel at a far greater speed than Ronald Fong's small fishing boat. Indicating that the 10-20 mph range of Ronald Fong's boat, and more likely the lower end estimate, is likely the correct one. 

Picture
But what time did the Zodiac Killer approach the couple. 
Bryan Hartnell estimated that "he thought suspect had been with the couple for approximately 15 minutes from time of observing suspect until suspect departed." Therefore, if the end of the attack was 6.12 pm, the Zodiac must have approached the couple at 5.57 pm. The distance from the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia to the crime scene was approximately 510 yards. Allowing for the terrain, and the time for the killer to hide behind the tree and don his costume, it would take approximately 7 minutes. This would have the Zodiac Killer spotting the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia at 5.50 pm, slightly earlier than the anticipated 6.00 pm in the previous article. But allowing for a little flexibility in the timeline and taking the end of the attack at 6.17 pm, would have the killer approaching the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia at 5.55 pm, only five minutes out from the previous article. Had the attack finished at 6.12-6.17 pm, then Zodiac would be writing on the car door at 6.19-6.24 pm.
Keeping a tight timeline, with Ronald Fong's boat traveling between 10-20 mph, the end of the attack on the young couple never would have exceeded 6.23 pm. His small boat was extremely unlikely to have reached anything in excess of this range, and indicates the Zodiac Killer more than likely 'signed' the car door by at least 6:30 pm, or possibly slightly earlier. 
The last article theorized Zodiac's vehicle just over a mile north of this location. However, if he had parked by the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia, the Zodiac Killer could have had anywhere from 70-80 minutes for his 40-50 minute journey to the payphone in Napa, indicating he either went off route on the return journey, he stopped or was delayed somewhere, or his vehicle wasn't parked behind the Volkswagen Karmann Ghia of Bryan Hartnell. 
But why did Ronald Fong, if he frequented the area regularly, travel 3.7 miles north to the Rancho Monticello Resort for help, when he could have traveled 0.7 miles south, directly to Park Headquarters.  

LAKE BERRYESSA- A KILLER'S TIMELINE [PART ONE]

THE SECOND 'ZODIAC' ON JACKSON STREET

$
0
0
Here we will take one final look at the vital four minutes from the time of the attack on Paul Stine, detailed in the police report as 9.55 pm, and the sighting of an unknown white male by the intersection of Jackson and Maple by Donald Fouke at 9.59 pm.
It is often claimed that trying to break down a timeline to individual seconds can lead to incorrect conclusions, and that is a worthy contention. However, when the discrepancy is so extremely glaring, then it is simply something that should not be overlooked. In major investigations involving many suspects, it is imperative to interview each and break down the movements of the individual around the relevant time period to consider the validity of their claims. Timelines are crucial in identifying unachievable claims, or including and excluding suspects from the investigation.
There is a very real possibility that two individuals were present in the taxicab that night, and the white male subject observed by Officer Donald Fouke approaching the intersection of Jackson and Maple was not the white male subject observed in and around the taxicab on October 11th 1969, but both were present as it pulled up to the corner of Washington and Cherry Street at 9.55 pm.
To shoot a taxicab driver in the wealthy district of Presidio Heights, then carefully tear a rectangular piece of the victim's shirt to take from the crime scene is extremely daring. But to then remove his keys and wallet, wipe down the taxicab, and inexplicably attempt to pull Paul Stine into an upright position behind the steering wheel on a busy Saturday night, with the certain conviction that nobody has heard the gunshot and called police, is bordering on insanity. This whole sequence of events from murdering the taxicab driver to leaving the crime scene, we would have to believe took just 60 seconds.      
Picture
It is without doubt the author of the 'Bus Bomb' letter mailed on November 9th 1969 was a participant in the murder one month earlier. The statement in the letter claiming "2 cops pulled a goof about 3 min after I left the cab," is not only proof he knew the exact time of the murder, but had knowledge that two police officers in a vehicle were present near the intersection of Jackson and Maple at the correct time that night. This information was never published in the newspapers.
Officers Donald Fouke and Eric Zelms received the police dispatch of an assault and robbery of a taxicab driver at 9.58 pm. This dispatch was also received at 9.58 pm by Armond Pelissetti and Frank Peda while patrolling along Washington Street.
Pelissetti and Peda arrived at the murder scene a little before 9.59 pm. 
The journey time is 1 minute for Donald Fouke and Eric Zelms to reach the intersection of Jackson and Maple from their location on Presidio Avenue, upon receiving the initial radio broadcast, where they spotted the unknown white male, seemingly the one who described the "2 cops who pulled a goof." 
This places Donald Fouke at the intersection of ​Jackson and Maple at 9.59 pm. Armond Pelissetti arrived at the intersection of Washington and Cherry just shy of 9.59 pm. But how do we know Armond Pelissetti arrived at the crime scene nearing 9.59 pm. The answer lies in the expanded statement of the three teenage eyewitnesses that night: 
"As both Robbins kids were the oldest, their statements were the given the most weight. Also they were the least traumatized by the event. One of the kids (not sure which) noticed a cab parked outside (in that now famous spot) with the interior lights on. So when Lindsey told me that the light inside the car was like a spotlight, it was so bright.
The first kid at the window said the driver looked "sick, or something". Lindsey and Rebecca went to the window and saw the driver laying across the front seat, head toward the passenger door. His head was in the lap of another man (passenger). Rebecca saw blood and said out loud, "he's stabbing that man." She was seeing blood on the victim and saw the glint of a knife, so she assumed a stabbing was taking place. (No shots were heard by anyone). We know now that Zodiac was cutting off a large piece of Stine's shirt with the knife.
At this time, Lindsey went downstairs to get a better look at what was happening, while one of the kids upstairs called the police. Downstairs, the lights were off, so Lindsey knew he could not be seen from the outside. He got close to the window and watched his actions. He was shortly joined by Rebecca. They both watched and observed in silence as Zodiac pushed the driver to an upright position behind the steering wheel, exited the car and walked around the rear of the car and opened the driver's door. Stine had fallen over onto the seat and Zodiac pulled him back up into the seated position and had some difficulty keeping him upright. Once upright, he was seen to have a rag, or something like a handkerchief and began to wipe down the door area and leaning over the driver, part of the dashboard. When he was finished, Zodiac calmly walked to Cherry St. and walked north.
Not many know this, but Lindsey (being 16. feeling immortal, and believing the suspect to be armed with only a knife) ran out of his door to see where Zodiac was going. He ran to the corner of Cherry and watched as Zodiac continued his casual pace right up to the corner of Jackson & Cherry.

At this exact point, the first SFPD car arrives with two officers. One, Pelissetti, approached Lindsey and tried to extract what was happening. The other officer went to the cab and found the bloody victim. While Pelissetti was asking questions, Lindsey was trying to explain that the suspect was in sight on Cherry St. By the time Pelissetti got the point, they both looked and the Zodiac was gone."

Picture
The key line here is the last one. Lindsey was trying to show Armond Pelissetti the subject nearing the top of Cherry Street before he disappeared along Jackson Street. The journey time from the intersection of Washington and Cherry to the top of Cherry Street is approximately 1 minute. The remaining journey time from here to Jackson and Maple is 2 minutes. The total journey time is about 3 minutes, exactly as 'Zodiac' had claimed in the 'Bus Bomb' letter: "2 cops pulled a goof about 3 min after I left the cab."  Donald Fouke spotted the unknown white male at 9.59 pm, meaning the subject left the taxicab at around 9.56 pm.
The unknown white male taking the journey time of 1 minute up Cherry Street would place him near the top of Cherry Street at 9.57 pm, where Lindsey pointed him out to Armond Pelissetti as he arrived at the scene. This is where a major problem arises. Armond Pelissetti didn't even get the initial broadcast until 9.58 pm, and still had to travel to the scene "red light and siren."  
Let us assume Armond Pelissetti was only 20 seconds away from the crime scene when he got the radio dispatch. He brings his police car to a halt at the junction, then approaches Lindsey, and "
while Pelissetti was asking questions, Lindsey was trying to explain that the suspect was in sight on Cherry St." Attributing all of this only 30 seconds, which is highly unlikely, would mean the time after the initial radio dispatch of 9.58 pm, was now 9.58:30 pm, the time he saw the subject at the top of Cherry. But we know that the subject was there at 9.57 pm based on everything above. According to the timeline of Donald Fouke the subject left the taxicab at 9.56 pm, so how could he have been spotted 2 1/2 minutes later at the top of Cherry Street, at 9.58:30 pm. Even using this stringent timeline there is a discrepancy of 90 seconds over the length of Cherry. Another way of looking at it, is that only 30 seconds after the initial radio broadcast the timeline is already out by a minimum of 90 seconds. If Armond Pelissetti took a more reasonable 1 minute to arrive, park up and meet with Lindsey, the time would be one minute after the broadcast, a time of 9.59 pm, when he was made aware of the subject nearing the top of Cherry. This however, is the same time that Donald Fouke spotted the subject nearing the intersection of Jackson and Maple. A discrepancy of two whole minutes.
This discrepancy over 10, 20, 30, or 60 minutes could possibly be explained away, but this discrepancy of two minutes, only one minute after the initial radio broadcast, is something that cannot be explained away by an argument of nitpicking the timeline.
In the 2007 Zodiac documentary Armond Pelissetti stated he "got down to the corner of Jackson Street. Had to make a choice. I was on the east side of the street so I turned right to the east and went up in that direction." The question is, did he make that choice because of Lindsey pointing the subject out to him, a more realistic reason to why he headed east.      

Therefore we have the white male subject at the top of Cherry Street at 9.59 pm, and at the intersection of Jackson and Maple at 9.59 pm, which clearly is not possible, unless they are two different people. Lindsey had tracked the movements of the subject in and around the taxicab that night, as well as when he rounded the corner to head up Cherry Street, so we know this person was involved in the crime. Could he have entered Jackson Street and was able to see the red light and siren of Donald Fouke at the other end of Jackson Street pulling over an innocent pedestrian. Then referencing this in his 'Bus Bomb' letter a month later, to give the impression that it was actually him Donald Fouke had spoken to. This is highly unlikely, because this person, had he been an innocent pedestrian, would not have directed Donald Fouke away from the crime scene toward Arguello Boulevard, as Donald Fouke stated in the 1989 'Crimes of the Century' documentary
"We proceeded on Jackson Street towards Arguello continuing our search, as we arrived at Arguello Street the description of the suspect was changed to a white male adult, believing this suspect was possibly the one involved in the shooting we entered the Presidio of San Francisco and conducted a search on West Pacific Avenue, the opposite side of the wall and the last direction we observed the suspect going, we did not find the suspect."  
Why would Donald Fouke be heading away from an assault and robbery to which he was supposed to be responding towards.
The likely answer is contained in the 'Bus Bomb' letter: "
2 cops pulled a goof abot 3 min after I left the cab. I was walking down the hill to the park when this cop car pulled up + one of them called me over + asked if I saw anyone acting suspicious or strange in the last 5 to 10 min + I said yes there was this man who was runnig by waveing a gun & the cops peeled rubber."  The white male subject sent them on a wild goose chase, knowing that, presented with the option of the police further questioning him, or burning rubber to protect the public from a man waving a gun, the police would choose to quell the imminent threat. Which is why Donald Fouke went off route, away from the crime scene towards Arguello Boulevard. They likely made the correct call at the time, as they were on the lookout for a male negro adult. Unfortunately they were duped by the man they stopped. Therefore it is highly unlikely this man was an innocent pedestrian, rather somebody with a more sinister motive, and likely the man who penned the November 9th 1969 'Bus Bomb' letter. We effectively have more than one Zodiac.     
Picture
These are the three descriptions of the unknown male, given by Officer Donald Fouke, the three teenagers, and eyewitnesses at Spruce Street moments after the 'meeting' at Jackson and Maple.
Spruce Street was situated just over one block east and was indirectly referenced in the 'Bus Bomb' letter: "I said yes there was this man who was runnig by waveing a gun & the cops peeled rubber + went around the corner as I directed them + I disappeared into the park a block + a half away never to be seen again."
Donald Fouke's description of the likely Zodiac Killer was "WMA, 35-45 yrs, about 5'10", 180-200 lbs, medium heavy build, barrel chested, medium complexion, light colored hair possibly graying in rear, crew cut, wearing glasses. Dressed in dark blue waist length zipper type jacket (Navy or royal blue). Elastic cuffs and waist band zipped part way up. Brown wool pants pleated type baggy in rear (Rust brown). "  
Here is the description given by the teenagers, who observed the Zodiac Killer in and around the taxicab on Washington Street from a residence across the street: "A white male, 25-30 years old, 5'8" to 5'9", stocky build, reddish-brown hair worn in a crew cut, heavy rimmed glasses and dark clothing."
The October 12th 1969 San Francisco article detailed the sighting of a man entering Julius Khan playground: "Later reports indicated someone was seen running into Julius Khan playground in the Presidio, and all seven police dog units were pressed into the search. The suspect was described as white, about 40, 170 pounds, a blond crewcut, warning glasses."   
One thing to notice in the latter two sightings, is the man appeared to have aged considerably and his hair had changed color. This doesn't mean it was a different person, but opens up the possibility that it may have been two separate individuals, both of whom were present in the taxicab as it approached the intersection of Washington and Cherry. Although the descriptions varied slightly, they must have been somewhat similar, as Donald Fouke did not contradict the sketch created by the three teenagers,  only describing the man as "older and heavier". Were the perpetrators related by blood, or had they employed disguises, something that was mentioned by the author of the November 9th 1969 'Bus Bomb' letter.
The first assailant shot the taxicab driver at 9.56 pm and departed the crime scene immediately. He was spotted by Officer Donald Fouke three minutes later at the intersection of Jackson and Maple at 9.59 pm, corroborated by the 'Bus Bomb' letter: "2 cops pulled a goof about 3 min after I left the cab." The second assailant was the one spotted by the three teenagers, indicating they looked out of the window after the first assailant had left. This man spent two minutes wiping down the taxicab, tearing the section of Paul Stine's shirt, removing the keys and wallet, and attempting to lift Paul Stine into an upright position behind the steering wheel, before leaving at 9.58 pm. Armond Pelissetti receives the initial radio broadcast at 9.58 pm and arrives en scene just shy of 9.59 pm, at which point the second assailant is approaching the top of Cherry Street, and is pointed out by Lindsey. This totally explains the discrepancy in the timeline.       

Picture
This may possibly explain the evident lack of urgency displayed by the second assailant in and around the taxicab that night. Had the police arrived earlier, his actions could have been explained as an innocent passer-by, who noticing the stricken taxicab driver had ripped a portion of shirt to staunch the blood flow. He wasn't in possession of the 'smoking gun', so how could he be the killer. When he realized the police were not upon him, his last action was to grab the keys from the ignition, and head in the same direction as his accomplice. If he was attempting to lift Paul Stine into an upright position, this would certainly explain why bloodied fingerprints were discovered on the dividing panel to the right of the driver side door, which clearly he would have used to brace himself. But why he was doing it, one can only conjecture.
Lindsey was fairly clear in the details observed that night, particularly in the attempt to draw Armond Pelissetti's attention to the white male heading up Cherry Street. If this recollection is accurate, then the man observed walking towards Jackson Street was not the same subject spotted by Donald Fouke as he approached the intersection of Jackson and Maple. These two men were separated by two full minutes. If the account by Lindsey is flawed, then the idea of an accomplice dissolves away into the night, just like the lone Zodiac Killer.  

THE RIVERSIDE PROPHECY [PART TWO]

$
0
0
Just a quick recap of the article 'The Riverside Prophecy.'
The Zodiac Killer finished many of his communications with the running victim total. The Dripping Pen card gave us the time, in the form of a month, and the total. The Bus Bomb letter stated "up to the end of Oct I have killed 7 people."
The July 31st 1969 San Francisco Chronicle letter warned us of future murders "If you do not print this cipher by the afternoon of Fry.1st of Aug 69, I will go on a kill ram-Page Fry. night." The Halloween card is also believed by many to be a future threat towards Paul Avery.
What if we apply the same model to the Riverside Desktop Poem, where he signs off the poem with "Just wait till next time. rh." The Riverside Desktop Poem was discovered in the December of 1966. But it might very well have been written prior to the murder of Cheri Jo Bates on October 30th 1966, and the warning of "Just wait till next time. rh." was referring to the time and place of his next murder. Remember, the author of the Confession letter had suggested he was trying to lure Cheri Jo Bates into his vehicle. This may possibly indicate he had planned to murder Cheri Jo Bates later than the believed 10.30 pm, when screams emanated from the alleyway, likely on Halloween Day itself, but something clearly had resulted in the unplanned struggle in the alleyway and her 'premature' murder from the perspective of the killer. Had he achieved his objective in luring the young woman into his vehicle, the likely prediction of the Riverside Desktop Poem would have come true. "Just wait till next time. riverside, halloween."
 

PictureClick to enlarge
The 'Confession' letter ended with a threat: "Beware I am stalking your girls now." The Riverside Desktop Poem equally ended with a threat: possibly "Just wait till next time. riverside, halloween."  If it was the time and place of the next murder, what is the chance that the Bates letters mailed to Joseph Bates,  the Riverside Press Enterprise and the Riverside Police were also threatening a date and place of a further murder, but not necessarily one that came to fruition.
Many have speculated the author of the Bates letters signed off two of the communications with the letter Z. However, they have a misshapen upper portion, leading to the idea they could again be two letters, in similar vein to the Riverside Desktop Poem. Despite being joined, the nearest they resemble is the letter M followed by an L.
Bearing in mind the Riverside Desktop Poem may have been written in the early part of October, before the murder of Cheri Jo Bates, it was thought that the letter H possibly represented Halloween, thereby presenting an imminent threat.
The Bates letters were mailed on April 30th 1967. An imminent threat in this case, bearing in mind April was drawing to a close, would have been the month of May. This would provide the time or date, but what about the location. 
Many killers will employ a 'buffer zone' to their residence, or a distance they can afford to travel without raising suspicion. Using the most basic form of geographical profiling, we shall look for a home location equidistant from the crime scene of the Cheri Jo Bates murder on Terracina Drive, and an area targeted in the month of May with the letter L.​           

PictureCheri Josephine Bates
One thing to consider first, is the evidence discovered in the alleyway close to Cheri Jo Bates' body.
The Department of Justice report described the heel prints at the Cheri Jo Bates crime scene as "those worn by Air Force personnel" and "was identified as a B.F. Goodrich waffle design, men's four-eighths inch washer type half heel. The B.F Goodrich Products Division of Akron, Ohio, reported that this type heel is only sold to the Federal prison industries at Leavenworth, Kansas. It was subsequently learned that Federal prison industries made low quarter military type shoes and supplied them to all the armed services using black dress shoes. The measurement of the heel indicated that it would have been attached to an eight to ten size shoe. Shoes bearing the same type heel were issued and sold at the PX at March Air Force Base in Riverside." In fact the Riverside Police Department would sum this up by stating "Physical evidence found at our crime scene indicated that heel prints found by the body were made by a heel that was manufactured for military and other government agencies, including prisons." 
So let us look at March Air Force Base. This base is
14 miles from Terracina Drive, and is located 12 miles from Lakeview, almost equidistant between the two. Did our suspect reside at the March Air Force Base, and was setting his 'buffer zone' around this location. Lakeview is bordered by the Upland Game Hunting Area.
Leading to the the slim chance the threat on the Bates letters may possibly be "BATES HAD TO DIE THERE WILL BE MORE. MAY LAKEVIEW". 
This is highly unlikely, because the author would then have joined two letters, something he didn't feel the need to do on the Riverside Desktop Poem, so if anybody can suggest another possible answer, please do not hesitate in offering your ideas in the comments section below.

Picture
The extreme left image is the Latin letter Z with a swash tail. 
In 1931, it was adopted into the orthography of Shona for a 'whistled' z, but it was dropped in 1955 due to the lack of the character on typewriters and fonts
. Wikipedia.
The image in the middle is the character rotated through 180 degrees, similar to the method Zodiac employed in his '13 Hole' and 'Pines' card, mailed on October 5th 1970 and March 22nd 1971 respectively.
 The Image on the immediate left is one of the Bates symbols. 

Shona: "
According to Shona tradition, the afterlife does not happen in another world like Christian heaven and hell, but as another form of existence in the world here and now. The Shona attitude towards dead ancestors is very similar to that towards living parents and grandparents." link.

THE RIVERSIDE PROPHECY [PART ONE]

IN THE SHADOWS OF THE COLLEGE

$
0
0
In the aftermath of the Cheri Jo Bates murder in Riverside on October 30th 1966 a library reconstruction was performed on November 13th 1966, with fingerprints and hair samples taken from the attendees to compare to crime scene evidence. How many college students and personnel were ultimately screened can only be speculated, but it was likely extensive. But who on the fringes of Riverside City College slipped through the net. Riverside College was undergoing extensive renovation at the time and was likely a hub of activity, that included contractors employed for this very task. Who could travel unhindered around the college campus, with access to buildings usually considered off limits. The murder was committed at the end of October, with the Bates letters mailed on April 30th 1967. We are looking at a period of 6 months, before the Zodiac Killer disappeared and apparently resurfaced in Benicia just over one and a half years later. If the Zodiac Killer was responsible for the events in Riverside, then it is conceivable, that if he worked around or within the Riverside City College campus, he took his profession with him when he resumed his murderous activities in northern California.   
The focus of our killer seemed to centralize around the Riverside College campus. We shall therefore look at some key bullet points. 
PictureIn the side corridor of the library annex. Conditions were so congested at the RCC Library (then located in the Quadrangle’s room 144) that the adjoining northern corridor of the Quad was enclosed and turned into a study room to somewhat alleviate overcrowding. This area remained enclosed until the 1980s when it was returned to its original look. Not believed to be Cheri Jo Bates.in the photograph. Click the image for enhanced look at the woman in the photograph.
#1. Cheri Jo Bates arrived at the campus shortly after 6.00 pm,  but screams were heard from the alleyway circa 10.30 pm. What  happened during this time period is unknown, but the killer  specifically targeted Cheri Jo Bates Volkswagen Beetle and may have remained on site for upwards of four hours.
Does this suggest he was comfortable in these surroundings and could travel around the campus largely unnoticed. Did the killer have access to a building in the vicinity of the library annex. Was he able to approach Cheri Jo Bates, only because he was familiar to her, yet he wasn't a close friend or fellow student.
#2. The two buildings either side of the crime scene were unoccupied. Would a killer lure a woman into this particular alleyway and commit a brutal attack, lasting possibly a minute or more, if he thought that these dwellings were inhabited by potential eyewitnesses, or even park his vehicle nearby.
This goes to the very heart of whether this perpetrator knew the status of these two buildings and the area he was operating in. Knowing in advance that nobody was overlooking the crime scene was seemingly fundamental to his escape from justice.
#3. A Timex watch was ripped from the murderer's wrist during the struggle. It carried white flecks of paint. Did this belong to a worker, somebody who was involved in the renovation of the campus facilities. 
#4. Here is a little background on the Riverside City College library: "The library is located on the Terracina Avenue side of the Quadrangle. Its collection included more than 35,000 books, 400 current periodicals and newspapers, 1,950 reels of microfilm and 2,000 pamphlets. Its indoor and outdoor facilities could accommodate 225 students. The library staff, included five professional librarians, who offered students and faculty individual assistance.
The services of the College Library were available to students and residents of the area without charge. Students had free access to any of the books and magazines in the collection and were encouraged to use the library for their recreational reading as well as for academic pursuits. The circulation period was flexible and was determined by the demand for the material in question. Usual loans were for three weeks, but shorter periods may have been required for assigned reading in limited materials. Longer loans could be made upon request. Borrowers were held responsible for any library materials which were lost or damaged while in their care. Hours of service were: Monday through Thursday 7:45 a.m. - 10:00 p.m.; Friday 7:45 a.m. - 4:30 p.m.; Sunday 1:00 - 5:00; 6:00 - 9:00 p.m."
    

Picture
Did the killer have access to the library facilities outside of hours.
Somewhere he could write unhindered on the library desktop, without fear that his unsavory poem could link him back to any murderous deeds he may commit. If the Riverside Desktop Poem was a precursor to the murder of Cheri Jo Bates, then an absence of onlookers would be preferential.
#5. The murderer of Cheri Jo Bates may equally have used other facilities from the library. The 'Confession' letters mailed by the killer on November 29th 1966 were several generation copies.
"A photocopying machine, where students could secure 8 1/2 X 11 inch black and white copy of printed or typed material, was available at the library for ten cents."
Photocopying an admission of murder in public may have been perilous, unless you could access such a machine in relative obscurity, such as a library during closing times.
#6. The photocopying machine would have been acquired by the college library in respect to the paper likely used by the college, staff and students alike. The three Bates letters mailed on April 30th 1967 measured 8 1/2 X 11 inches, identical to the size offered by the photocopier in the library. 

Picture
#7"An unrelenting search had been in progress for the murder weapon, and that Tuesday detectives used a metal detector in shrubbery adjacent to the murder scene in an effort to find the knife used by the slayer. Captain Cross revealed to the news media that the autopsy showed that the murder weapon was probably a pocket knife with a 3 inch blade or less. The broadcast and published information about the knife caused the police switchboard to be flooded with calls reporting knives of similar description being found all over the city of Riverside." 
On November 14th 1966, one day after the highly publicized library reconstruction, the police did get a call from a Riverside City College gardener: "That he had unearthed a hunting knife with his rake. The knife had apparently been buried near the murder scene. Detectives hurried to the campus and turned over the knife to the homicide detail. However, examination failed to show any evidence of dried blood on the knife blade. Also, its width did not compare with the incisions made by the stab wounds."
Did the killer plant this knife to play games with the police, possibly observing them from the campus grounds as a casual onlooker. Was the murderer familiar with the routine of the college gardener, knowing he would eventually unearth the knife, or did he make a call to police, something that was withheld from the newspapers.
#8. The 'Confession' letter stated "She was young and beautiful but now she is battered and dead. She is not the first and she will not be the last. I lay awake at night thinking about my next victim. May'be she will be the beautiful blond that babysits near the little store and walks down the dark alley each evening about seven. Or may'be she will be the shapely brownette that said no when I asked her for a date in high school. But may'be it will not be either."
Was the killer referring to the alleyway where Cheri Jo Bates was murdered. Could he have been present on the Riverside College campus throughout this period, perfectly visible, yet at the same time inconspicuous because of his connection to the college. 
What, if anything, was significant about the month delay in claiming the crime in the 'Confession' letter. Was this indicative of how close he was to the college, or was the author a hoaxer, simply reading the newspaper reports and leading us on a merry Danse Macabre.

THE FOURTH PIECE OF PAUL STINE'S SHIRT?

$
0
0
In 2007, the David Fincher 'Zodiac' film burst onto our cinema screens to bring a new audience to the now 49 year old murder mystery. The film was based on the 1986 Robert Graysmith book, but employed many previous investigators as consultants or technical advisors to the film, such as George Bawart, Russell T Butterbach, Pierre Bidou, Kelly Carroll, Donald Fouke, Armond Pelissetti, Ken Narlow and Dave Toschi, to name but a few. 
The film does provide a good overview of the Zodiac case, although clearly employs a fair degree of artistic license not based in fact. However there is one key scene that we shall focus on here- the scene where the 'Halloween' card arrives at the San Francisco Chronicle headquarters and a piece of Paul Stine's shirt is discovered in the greetings card. 
The Zodiac Killer mailed three pieces of Paul Stine's shirt, firstly in the October 13th 1969 letter, secondly in the November 9th 1969 'Bus Bomb' letter and thirdly to Melvin Belli on December 20th 1969, but no mention was ever given to a fourth swatch of Paul Stine's being received with any subsequent correspondence. The film had been accurate in this respect, so why was it necessary to invent this portion of the story when the 'Halloween' card stood on its own merits as a Zodiac correspondence, being perceived as a personal threat to newspaper reporter Paul Avery. With many previous and current investigators involved in the film, this seemed an unnecessary addition of fiction. Unless of course it wasn't.
The Zodiac did not mail the entirety of the shirt section he removed from the taxicab driver on October 11th 1969, and we have come to believe he wasn't a collector of souvenirs. So why didn't he just mail back the remainder of the shirt in later communications, particularly ones he must have realized would be questioned as authentic correspondence from the killer.       
PictureImage from the 2007 David Fincher Zodiac movie
This is not claiming a piece of shirt did arrive with the 'Halloween' card, but is looking for reasons why it could be a possibility based on the card's contents. 
There would seem little reason to withhold this from the newspapers when previous pieces received had been fully disclosed. Despite this, in 1970, certain details contained in several correspondences were withheld from publication, most notably the whole of the 'Little List' letter mailed on July 26th 1970, eventually released to the press on October 12th 1970, only two weeks prior to the arrival of the 'Halloween' card. Whether the investigators were trying to force a mistake from Zodiac by 'interfering' with his communications can only be surmised. 
The immediate communication after the disappearance of Donna Lass on September 6th 1970 was the Zodiac '13 Hole' postcard containing a pasted red crucifix. In later years a potential burial site was explored by Officer Harvey Hines near Clair Tappaan Lodge, where a rock configuration of 13 stones were positioned in the form of a cross. It was considered that Zodiac may have been pointing us toward the burial site of Donna Lass. The area he had concealed her remains.
​Was the 'Halloween' card also pointing us toward an area of concealment in a rather more subtle way. The author of the 'Halloween' card had certainly made great effort in creating additions to this card, in similar fashion to the '13 Hole' postcard, but obviously in a more magnified fashion. What purpose belied the addition of a pumpkin over the pelvis of the first skeleton, as well as adding the second skeleton on the card inner. If indeed this held great purpose, then it was largely missed by most observers. One would like to believe the pumpkin and skeleton were placed on the card for more than just the casual amusement of its creator. That is what we shall investigate.    
   

PictureClick image to view card inner
The first thing to look at is "peek-a-boo you are doomed," a perceived threat to newspaper reporter Paul Avery, placed around the knothole of the tree on the card inner. 
Peek-a-boo is a form of play, where a parent for example, may cover their face with their hands, and then reveal themselves to the infant, exclaiming peekaboo. Was this Zodiac patronizing his investigators, painting himself as the parent while subtly mocking the police and journalists as children, warning them they were "doomed." In addition, was it suggestive of something hidden that was about to be revealed. The eye in the knothole telling us to look closer.
The Zodiac Killer could have drawn on the 'Halloween' card, but chose to add a cut out pumpkin and skeleton. The inside of the envelope contained the phrase "sorry no cipher" twice, formed into an X formation. There may have been no cipher, but was the X marking a location to be found.
The pumpkin on the card outer was fashioned over the pelvic region of the skeleton, only to be effectively removed from the skeleton on the card inner, to the delight of the author in the form of the word "Boo." Again, an extension of something concealed to the observer, before its unearthing. Everything in the card screams out to something hidden that will be revealed. If the Zodiac Killer didn't place a small piece of Paul Stine's shirt behind the pumpkin, it could be argued he missed a Halloween trick, or treat in his case. He drew a styled red mask on the eyes of the inner skeleton, that likely in the real world would be made of fabric, that once again hints at concealment.
It has also been noted by many observers that the inner skeleton is somewhat posed in the fashion of Paul Stine lying prostrate in the taxicab- the mask on the skeleton's eyes depicting the strategically placed black rectangle over the face of Paul Stine, in respect of dignity and sensitivity. But was a small swatch of shirt, similar in size to the mask, concealed under the pumpkin.      

Picture
The Zodiac Killer may have written 14 on the 'Halloween' card three times. Firstly, the number fourteen on the hand of the outer skeleton. Secondly, in the form of 4-TEEN above the head of the inner skeleton. And thirdly, in the form of a strange symbol at the foot of the card inner, which may represent 'Zodiac Victims Fourteen' or 'Zodiac Fourteen.'  There may however be another possibility, based on the 'four eyes' near the pelvic region of the skeleton, and near the strange symbol at the foot of the card, where the Zodiac Killer curiously added four dots.
The Bay Area killer certainly was indicating 14 victims, or a potential 14 victims, however he also appeared to be emphasizing the number 4.
He deliberately separated the number fourteen to create 4-TEEN.
He placed four larger eyes close to the pelvic region of the skeleton, as if urging us to see something, along with the four dots around the symbol.
Could the symbol stand for 'Zodiac Four,' or was it still 'Zodiac Victims Fourteen,' with four attachments to date- The fourth piece of Paul Stine's shirt concealed under the pumpkin by the pelvic region of the outer skeleton, highlighted by the four large eyes imploring us to discover.  
The Zodiac Killer mailed the 'Halloween' card just after the first anniversary of the Presidio Heights murder, so if he was to send any more pieces of Paul Stine's shirt, this may have been his opportune moment. But we are led to believe he didn't, and nothing presented above can fully convince otherwise.         

MIDNIGHT COWBOY

$
0
0
The 'Exorcist' letter was mailed to the San Francisco Chronicle on January 29th 1974 - to some a form of epitaph to his impending death by suicide. The final paragraph however warned "If I do not see this note in your paper, I will do something nasty, which you know I'm capable of doing," seemingly contradictory to this notion. The letter opened in mocking fashion, describing the recently released Exorcist film as "the best saterical comidy that I have ever seen." 
Was he constructively criticizing the film, or had its content of exorcism hit closer to home from the point of homosexuality.
On October 18th 1969 Paul Avery ran a piece in the San Francisco Chronicle describing the Zodiac Killer as a 'latent homosexual'. Under the banner Zodiac-Portrait of the Killer  he stated "The killer of five who calls himself 'Zodiac' is a clumsy criminal, a liar and possibly a latent homosexual." This was covered extensively in two articles, Skeleton in the Closet and What a Drag, and we shall explore this possibility further in respect the October 11th 1969 murder of Paul Stine.
This was the late 1960s, a time when the gay community suffered unspeakable prejudice from the police, authorities and a seeping religious intolerance. Christian fundamentalists, cloaked in toxic reverence of themselves, believed incorrectly, by summoning the will of God upon the person with homosexual feelings, that the devil could be driven out of their body and thus cleanse their soul. It therefore wouldn't be a great leap of faith to believe that the Zodiac Killer had utter contempt for this form of religious piety and the practice of exorcism, hence the description of The Exorcist movie as the "the best saterical comidy that I have ever seen." ​This contempt for the police and newspapers may have been well founded, as arrested gay individuals had their names and addresses routinely published in the newspapers as a form of public shaming.​ 
PictureWestin St. Francis Hotel, 335 Powell Street, San Francisco
The Zodiac Killer would reference the film Badlands on May 8th 1974 and the Red Phantom movie, also known as El Espectro Rojo on July 8th 1974, which had a showing at the Lyric Theater in Mill Valley at the end of April. The Zodiac Killer certainly appeared to have a penchant for the theatrical, with his references to The Mikado in his correspondence, and his 'grand curtain call' at Lake Berryessa on September 27th 1969. However, did this extravagance for attention spill out into his personal life.
Did these 'attractions' for Zodiac have any bearing on his movements in the hours prior the murder of Paul Stine. 
Taking meter readings from the taxicab at the crime scene and information acquired by Robert Graysmith and Officer Harvey Hines, it was believed the Zodiac entered the taxicab of Paul Stine outside the Westin St Francis Hotel in Union Square. But where had he been in the hours preceding this fateful journey.
The 'Exorcist' letter was without doubt a response to the San Francisco Chronicle article entitled 'Weird Goings on at the Movies,' authored by Paul Avery and published on January 11th 1974, detailing the audience reaction to the recently released Exorcist movie in 1973. The news report was from the Northpoint Theatre, located at 2290 Powell Street, San Francisco. The theater was located 3.4 miles from Washington and Cherry Streets, the intersection where Paul Stine was murdered and only 1.3 miles from Union Square, where the taxicab driver picked up Zodiac.
The Exorcist movie opened its 26 week stint at the Northpoint Theatre on December 26th 1973 and had performances throughout the day. A typical schedule was 1.00 pm, 4.00 pm, 7.00 pm and 10.00 pm, for films two hours or longer.
The area where Paul Stine picked up the Zodiac Killer was the bustling theater district in San Francisco, so his perceived  leanings to the theatrical in his communications may have played a part in his choice of pick-up point. Had he just exited from an early evening performance? The arrival of the taxicab at the intersection of Washington and Cherry at 9.55 pm indicated a departure time of approximately 9.40 pm from Union Square, conducive to his exit from a nearby theater. The Westin St Francis Hotel may also have been familiar. Union Square borders the Nob Hill and Tenderloin districts, which combines both the LGBT and theater influences under one banner. Jose Sarria, a high profile San Francisco drag performer and gay activist  was arrested at the Westin St Francis public restrooms for solicitation, a location known to be frequented by homosexuals.

Picture
Had the Zodiac Killer been somewhere else that evening, rather than a stage performance. Could he have been viewing a movie at the Northpoint Theatre. A two hour film beginning at 7.00 pm and finishing at 9.00 pm, would leave a 25-30 minute walk back to Union Square, possibly with a quick takeaway, to enable the Zodiac Killer to enter Paul Stine's taxicab circa 9.40 pm. But what was playing at the Northpoint Theatre on October 11th 1969.
Midnight Cowboy ran from the 16th July 1969 to 17th December 1969.
The film, starring Dustin Hoffman and Jon Voight won three Academy AwardsBest PictureBest Director and Best Adapted Screenplay. It was the first gay-related Best Picture winner. In addition, it was the only X-rated film ever to win Best Picture.
Ironically, the film that preceded Midnight Cowboy was The Great Bank Robbery with writer William Blatty accredited for screenplay. 
Here is a very relevant clip from Midnight Cowboy, where Dustin Hoffman has an altercation with a Yellow taxicab driver. The taxicab incident in Midnight Cowboy was apparently not scripted in the film- but likely Zodiac's impending murder of Paul Stine was conceived beforehand, a predetermined reel of murder for which there was only one end.

THE ZODIAC KILLER'S STANFORD CONNECTION

$
0
0
Picture
"The following article was sent to me by Ray Jenkins, an amateur sleuth from Australia, regarding a connection between Zodiac and Stanford, Santa Clara County, California. It is an extremely interesting read, and remains unaltered. At the foot of this presentation I have placed a link to a Zodiac Ciphers article, relevant to this subject."
​ 

The Zodiac killer’s apparent interest in The Mikado has long puzzled many researchers and detectives. Recently I came across several articles in the Stanford Daily newspaper from the Zodiac era, which began to intrigue me and so I decided to dig a little deeper. A picture started to emerge and I believe I may be able to offer some plausible reasons for the Zodiac’s sojourns into Gilbert and Sullivan opera and his apparent interest in compass directions. In order to get my head around the articles, I decided to write up a chronological timeline of events, cross-referenced with some of the Zodiac’s timeline (following).

Zodiac's "Stanford" timeline:
July 31st 1969: The Zodiac first introduces the concept of "Paradice" in his letters.

August 4th 1969: The killer uses the name “Zodiac” for the first time.

October 24th 1969: The Stanford Daily publishes an article written by Craig Wilson which lampoons the San Francisco Examiner's recent letter to the Zodiac. Basically intended as playful satire, the author went so far as to deride the Zodiac and invites him to their next staff meeting. It read;
'Let there be no more killing. But if you must, try Paul McCartney. Police say you are intelligent. If you are, give yourself up and face execution. You are being hunted everywhere in he state and nation. But don't get jumpy. You are alone in this world. Have you noticed that most of your friends have deserted you? You are as much a victim of your crimes as those whose lives you snuffed out. Of course you do seem to be in better condition. You cannot walk the streets a free man. Of course, we have no idea who you are. But you will be caught, there is no doubt. The police have staked out every school bus in town and Melvin Belli has been made a permanent guest on every talk show in the Bay Area. You face life as a hunted, tormented animal—unless you help yourself. Surrender. We have plenty of cages available. We ask that you give yourself up to The Daily. We offer you no protection, and no sympathy. But we do offer you the best medical help available and all the benefits your legal rights afford. We offer you the opportunity to transfer into our fine institution. We offer you a trailer in Manzanita Park. We offer you a ticket to see Stanford in the Rose Bowl. We offer you all the plastic cups we can produce with your signature and photograph. The food service has consented to feed you chocolate ice cream even if it isn't available. We offer you a plastic dolly. We offer you a seat in the balcony at the flicks. We offer you credit in Professor Erlich's Population Biology course. And best of all we offer to tell YOUR STORY! Why have you killed? We will give you everything. Your horoscope for today says your anger at society is unwarranted, that you will soon come into great fortune. We offer you a subscription to Fortune magazine. We invite you to our staff meeting on Monday at noon. Lunch is free. If you have other things to do, call the Daily anytime. Ask for anyone. We are a community newspaper. The telephone number is 321-2300 x 4632. Call collect, what the hell. Your call will not be traced. We cordially invite our neighborly newspaper The Palo Alto Times to give you a better deal. Just cut your hair and mumble "kk l hate radicals." Chances are they will make a more promising overture. Just remember Mr. Zodiac, you are being hunted everywhere in he state and nation. There is no safety for you, anywhere.' http://stanforddailyarchive.com/

October 31st 1969. Dr John I. Maurer publishes a letter that is very critical of Craig Wilson’s satirical article. It is interesting that Dr Maurer chastises the letter writer, rather than directly warn about the obvious dangers of riling the Zodiac! Dr Maurer calls the letter "stupid", "tasteless" and "inappropriate", and "distressing" because of its "callous insensitivity" towards people with mental health problems. Perhaps the good doctor was merely trying to appease the Zodiac in the event that the killer actually did read the comments? I believe the man in the following link is the Dr John Maurer from that time, but I could be wrong. See: http://health.usnews.com/doctors/john-maurer and Stanford Daily Archive October 31st 1969

October 31st 1969: In the same issue of the Stanford Daily, appear two reviews on page 4, one about the recent Lamplighter performance of The Mikado, the other about Douglas Leedy's recently released album called ELECTRIC ZODIAC. The obvious coincidence with the name immediately caught my attention. I am sure if the Zodiac – egotist that he was - had been following these newspapers in case more articles were written about him, he too would have noticed the coincidence. Leedy was an early synthesizer pioneer and his album basically consists of various, repetitious, electronic blips, squeaks, and squawks which I can only guess may have seemed very experimental and “cool” at the time. Perhaps only the LSD-affected mind could fully appreciate his music’s experimental quality and simplicity? But for those of us today who grew up in the Commodore-64 era or later, the albums do seem rather lacklustre.

Picture
​A second interesting coincidence comes with the title of Douglas Leedy’s first album, a 3LP set called Entropical Paradise. Again, this title sets off some alarm bells for those who have researched the Zodiac case in any depth. In his letters the Zodiac killer often claimed to be killing people in order to collect slaves for his own future Paradise (which he spelt “Paradice”, perhaps as a result of poor spelling, or for another more plausible reason that I will raise later in this article). Whether Douglas Leedy’s albums influenced the Zodiac’s choice of name, or whether the Zodiac was a fan of electronic synth music, is anyone’s guess! I am merely highlighting the coincidence and the possible synchronicity with what followed.

Sandwiched between those two articles is one written by Marshall Schwartz which outlines a card "game". It contains diagrams showing NSWE seating. I found this very reminiscent of the Zodiac's NSWE compass diagrams which he provided in the Mt. Diablo letter. 

Below this article is a review of The Mikado, which the Zodiac later refers to in his "little list" letters of 24 July 1970 and 26 July 1970. A very observant friend of mine spotted another possible Zodiac-related "clue" in that same edition of the Stanford Daily. It is hidden right next to another of the articles from Oct 31, 1969. Stanford Daily Archive October 31st 1969

Picture
Scroll to the right and look at the cartoon - not the one below the letter - but the one on the next page. Read the writing on the bottle. It says; "TESTOR MODEL AIRPLANE CEMENT" (SEE ABOVE). In the Zodiac's Nov. 9, 1969 letter he said there are no fingerprints because he covers his fingers with "AIRPLANE CEMENT."

​And there is yet another very obvious “Zodiac” reference in the same edition (SEE RIGHT). The Stanford Daily, Volume 156, Issue 26, 31 October 1969 — Page 10 Advertisements Column 6 [ADVERTISEMENT].  
Stanford Daily Archive October 31st 1969

The cartoon is interesting for another reason too. Charles Manson often expressed a deep admiration and respect for the indigenous peoples of the Americas.

There could well be more of these kinds of clues and references in those papers, that could be found with a bit more digging. I note for example that Steve McQueen is also referenced in an advertisement right next to the Electric Zodiac article, and we now know McQueen was one of the prominent people on the Manson Family's "death list". 

Picture
​And this in turn fits well with the Zodiac's "Little List" of the people he disliked. There is a possible connection there.

I contend that the Zodiac did actually read the satirical letter in the Stanford Daily and he also read Dr. Maurer's reply. He has noticed the coincidental Electric Zodiac article on page 4 of that same newspaper, and has latched on to the NSWE diagrams and The Mikado article. I believe he has later adapted these ideas into his letters, Mt. Diablo map, and compass diagrams on 26 July 1970 and 26 June 1970 (e.g. "0 is to be set to Mag. N."), and his "little list" letters of 24 July 1970 and 26 July 1970. I therefore believe that the Zodiac got some of his ideas from the Stanford Daily issue of 31 October 1969.

Why he did this is anybody's guess. But in my opinion this may have been his way of replying to the derisive letter published about him on 24 October 1969. By referencing things from the newspaper and mixing them with implied threats, he was showing that he had not forgotten about the newspaper article.

This kind of behaviour is typical of a person that tends to hold grudges for a very long time. It is also highly suggestive of someone who is anti-social or sociopathic, perhaps also paranoid, and who obsesses over trivial details for very long periods.
This kind of person potentially has a photographic memory with a strong desire to continually recall and relive past events. We have seen ample evidence of this kind of ritualistic behaviour in other serial killers, such as “BTK”, Dennis Rader.

The title of Marshall Schwartz's article also interests me. He calls it "Doubled Up", which tends to refer to pairs of dice when referencing games of chance. And this makes me immediately think of the Zodiac's ideas of "games" and "paradice". The Zodiac may have intentionally spelt "paradice" that way in order to indicate an association with games and “pairs of dice”. However the Zodiac’s idea precedes the Stanford Daily articles by several months. In fact The Zodiac first introduces the concept of "Paradice" on 31 July 1969. But there is a semantic similarity evident between the words “Doubled up” and the Zodiac’s Mount “Diablo”.

​The Zodiac drew the following creepy picture in the infamous Halloween “BOO” card that he sent to Paul Avery at the San Francisco Chronicle on October 27th 1970. The card was clearly intended to rattle Avery. It has been speculated that the card may have been the Zodiac’s retaliation for Avery having called him a “latent homosexual” in one of his articles.​

Picture
​The Zodiac’s drawing of the intersecting Paradice/Slaves cross interests me for two reasons. Firstly it is a perfect match for the Order of the Rainbow for girls – an obscure but seemingly obvious Masonic reference for anyone who may be familiar with the symbol. The number of diamond characters on the Order of the Rainbow cross precisely matches the number of vertical letters in “PARADICE”. Also the off-centred balance of the “CROSS OF COLOUR” lettering matches well with the off-centre lettering of the Zodiac’s “SLAVES”. I have superimposed the two images (below) to illustrate this.

It is possible that the Zodiac was alluding to (or perhaps even playing homage to) Charles Manson’s Order of the Rainbow (ATWA), however ATWA was not widely known until the 1970s and it is difficult to know for sure exactly when the term was first coined. Also, the Order of Rainbows cross resembles a sword, which a devout Manson follower named Sandra Good drew in a rather Zodiac-esque sketch. 

PictureClick article for link
Now back to the timeline.
November 5th 1969: Someone claiming to be the Zodiac calls emergency and threatens to be on Stanford Campus in 10 minutes. Two hours later, nobody showed. This was possibly a hoax perpetrated by a student, and the entire story may be fictional, as campus rags sometimes invented such stories simply for their shock value. According to the article writer, the police took the matter very seriously. I cannot verify if this event actually took place in the days prior to 5 November, but I have a feeling the story may be true. Given that the Zodiac appears to have "borrowed" or rehashed ideas from that newspaper and re-worked them for his own agenda, does make it seem like he had revenge on his mind. 

October 12th 1974: Arlis Perry is murdered in STANFORD at the Stanford Memorial Church. The crime showed some of the hallmark modus operandi of the Zodiac killer. If he was responsible, was the Zodiac still enacting his revenge on Stanford? I wonder about this, given that the date of her killing was in October, the very same month in which Craig Wilson's satirical and mocking article appeared in the Stanford Daily !! Could the Zodiac have held a grudge for a full 5 years? I think he did, because less than 10 months beforehand he had repeated more lines from The Mikado in his so-called Exorcist letter of 29th Jan 1974: “He plunged himself into the billowy wave and an echo arose from the suicide's grave, titwillo titwillo titwillo”.

​Another point to note is that on the page immediately following Craig Wilson’s mocking and taunting letter to the Zodiac, there appeared an article about the Catholic faith and an advertisement for the Stanford Memorial Church! Coincidence? Well yes, the placement of the Stanford Memorial Church ad and the articles clearly were the result of chance, as they were never intended for the Zodiac. BUT the Zodiac was most likely a psychopath! At the very least he showed the capacity to be a vengeful egotist. I am convinced that the Zodiac selected various ideas from the same editions of the Stanford Daily that contained articles pertaining to him, and he found ways to incorporate those subjects and themes into his revenge. His aim was basically to “mock” and taunt Stanford in return, using the only methods that he believed he could control.

PictureArlis Perry. Click image for Wikipedia link.
April 26th 1978: Article published in Stanford Daily about the Zodiac's return to SF. http://stanforddailyarchive.com/cgi-bin/stanford-Zodiackiller
The Zodiac’s Revenge on Stanford?
Now I am the first to admit I know very little about psychopaths or how they think, but I believe many a psychopath has made it their mission in life to exact revenge against the people who they think have wronged them. I believe the Zodiac was egotistical and vindictive, and also vengeful.

I may have already provided a plausible reason for the Zodiac's sudden interest in seemingly disparate things like The Mikado and compass directions. I now think these were all a part of his crazy and elaborate way of expressing his revenge on the Stanford Daily newspaper for having mocked and taunted him. But apart from the threatening phone call, it is highly likely that none of the staff or students ever noticed the connections with the things the Zodiac was to later write about in his letters. If it is a case of what came first the chicken or the egg, it is very clear to me that from the above timeline the Stanford Daily newspaper articles came first and the Zodiac's rehashing of subject matter relating to articles from those same newspapers came later.

Listed below are some of the murders that occurred on Stanford University, or which involved recent graduates of the university, that I think can possibly be attributed to the Zodiac. I know I may be getting into Charles Manson, Ted Bundy / Son of Sam “territory" here, but I think it also intersects with what we know about the Zodiac.

I personally think that the Zodiac was out for revenge because of that derogatory student article about him in 1969. He wanted pay back and decided to take away some of Stanford's bright young people as a form of retribution. And moreover, in his typically cryptic and overthe-top manner, he had even tried to “clue people in” to this fact, perhaps even to warn them. 

​By referencing things from that same issue of the Stanford Daily, such as The Mikado - from a page that coincidentally also mentioned the name Zodiac - he was telling everybody that he had not forgotten about the article that had humiliated him. We should also remember that the 1969 article by Craig Wilson had also presented him with an open invitation to visit the campus at a day and time of his choosing. I personally believe the Zodiac followed up on this invitation in his own way.

As for why he didn't go after Craig Wilson or any of the other newspaper staff, I think this is in keeping with the Zodiac's M.O. He never went after Paul Avery or anyone else from the San Francisco Chronicle. But he would kill somebody else in a seemingly random and unmotivated way as a form of “payback”. He killed as if in a predatory and opportunistic manner. For the most part, he seemingly selected his victims at random, but we also know from his attack on two civilians at Lake Berryessa that he may have stalked some of his victims beforehand. The elaborate costume that he wore in this case suggested considerable advance planning.

We know from his letters, that the Zodiac intended any attack on an individual to have far greater meaning than the death of an individual. It was intended as an attack on an entire city or place e.g. “San Francisco” or “society” as a whole. Basically he wanted families to suffer, schools to mourn, and whole communities to tremble in fear. It was very much an anonymous ego trip for him. So I think when he decided to enact revenge on Stanford, the same rules applied. He selected young campus students and graduates – people who were not only loved and cherished, but potentially among Stanford’s brightest and best and most beautiful.

As to why the Zodiac fell silent early in 1974 is anyone’s guess. Some experts believe he got nervous after almost getting caught leaving the scene of Paul Stine’s murder. It is therefore possible that he was deliberately keeping a low profile or he may even have skipped town. Others speculate he may have committed suicide or ended up in a mental asylum. He may have been incarcerated after committing some other offense that was not linked to the Zodiac case. Then he just “fell through the cracks”. Of course, another theory is that he just kept on killing, but had decided not to advertise and boast about his crimes like before.

I am not saying that all of the following murders can be attributed to the Zodiac, but I think some of them possibly could be. 

February 13th 1973: Leslie Marie Perlov, 21, was found strangled in the foothills above Stanford University. The victim resided in Los Altos Hills. She was spotted lying in a clump of bushes with her blue scarf wrapped tightly around her neck. Authorities said she had been missing since Tuesday. An unidentified man was seen talking to someone in Miss Perlov's car. The incident occurred about three hours after Miss Perlov was seen leaving North County Law Library in Palo Alto where she worked as a clerk. Her car was found about three miles from the library. The car keys were missing. A helicopter search for Miss Perlov accidentally turned up the body of Mark Rosvoldt, 25 of Barron Park, an apparent suicide. A sawn off shotgun was at his side. Authorities said there was no apparent connection between the deaths, although both bodies were found in the same pasture. No leads or clues were present and the case went cold.  Stanford Daily Article 1  Stanford Daily Article 2
PictureAttendants remove the body of David Levine
September 11th 1973: David Sidney Levine, aged 19, a senior in physics from Ithaca, N.Y., was found early on the morning of Sept. 11 by a jogger. Levine’s body was found on a walkway just east of the Meyer Library. His assailant had stabbed him 15 times in the back and side with a long knife. He was last seen leaving the physics department at 1 a.m. The killing was perhaps motivated by a jealous rage from a fellow student, but no leads or clues were ever found. The use of a long-bladed knife and a seemingly unmotivated, unexpected, and random attack is highly reminiscent of the Zodiac’s M.O. Stanford Article.

March 24th 1974: Janet Ann Taylor, 21, daughter of former athletic director Chuck Taylor, was found strangled by hand near the intersection of Mayfield Ave. and Junipero Serra Blvd. The murder was strangely similar to Perlov’s: she too died by strangulation and was not molested. Her purses were missing and she was found barefoot in a raincoat. The theft of a trivial amount of money is reminiscent of the murder (attributed to the Zodiac) of taxi cab driver Paul Stine on 11 October 1969. Stanford Daily Article

Picture
October 12th, 1974:  Arlis Kay Perry was a 19-year-old newlywed murdered inside Stanford Memorial Church on October 12, 1974. Arlis Perry moved to Stanford University with her husband, who was a sophomore pre-med student. At the time of her murder, she'd been working as a receptionist at a local law firm. Her body was arranged in a symbolic shape very reminiscent of the symbolic shape used by the Zodiac on one of his mailed envelopes. Stanford Daily Article
Photograph on left: King of Hearts
And of course the central shape is again highly reminiscent of common Masonic symbolism. Other researchers have noted similarities with Satanic symbolism and in some cases possible ​

Picture
​Celtic and various pagan symbolism. The following illustrations show standard Masonic symbols, which bear a striking similarity to the Zodiac’s symbols.
And there was one more suspicious death involving a member of Stanford University. 

July 18th 1976: Edward McNeill, postdoctoral researcher in chemistry, was found strangled and bound with adhesive tape in his Menlo Park apartment.
"A coroner's examination indicated that he may have been bound with adhesive tape and strangled. The body of Edward McNeill. 25. was discovered Tuesday night by his landlady and a friend in his apartment at 782 Coleman Avenue. The coroner's examination disclosed that he had been dead for approximately two days and tentatively designated strangulation as the cause of death. The examination also discovered traces of adhesive tape on McNeill's hands and mouth. "We're still in the preliminary stages of the investigation," said Deputy Chief Robert Brickley of the Menlo Park police." Stanford Daily Article.

Picture
Manson and Zodiac’s Shared Symbolism. Charles Manson frequently used Masonic symbolism and also Satanic symbolism. He even borrowed concepts from the Masons, such as the Order of the Rainbow. I think he may have done this because his surname "Mason" was semantically similar to "Manson" and he was, of course, very fond of the idea of secretive cults and churches.

​Manson’s ATWA symbolism (see image on left) is remarkably like the Zodiac’s symbolism. This logically suggests the two identities may have been associated in some way. Many people claim the similarities are merely the result of coincidence or a desire for other anti-social types to "copy-cat" in order to gain publicity for their own crusades and agendas. It is of course possible that Manson merely borrowed the Zodiac's symbolism to help publicize his beliefs and agenda. Notoriety tends to breed notoriety, and we see other copycats like Son of Sam later trying to glom on to the Zodiac persona. Nevertheless there are some striking similarities in the symbolism. It would appear that some of the symbols used by the Zodiac were later rehashed by Manson, however some of Manson's symbols may have actually predated their use by the Zodiac. Here is a sample of ATWA symbolism from the Manson cult. Symbol for Air, Trees, Water, Animals. I cannot help but notice that the shape is very reminiscent of the body arrangement of Arlis Perry at the Stanford Memorial Church. There has long been speculation that either Manson or the Zodiac were responsible for her murder, however the finger has also been pointed at obscure Satanic cults.
Thanks again to Ray Jenkins.

Message to the Zodiac Killer 


340 CIPHER- EMBEDDED SYMMETRY

$
0
0
Picture
This is a rehash of earlier articles concerning the 340 cipher and 13 Symbol cipher, regarding their symmetry and correlation to one another. If you are familiar with the 888 theory, then you need go no further.
The 340 cipher was the second cipher mailed on November 8th 1969- the 13 symbol cipher was the third cipher mailed on April 20th 1970, separated by just over five months. The Zodiac would refer to his 340 cipher at the beginning of the April 20th letter, stating: "This is the Zodiac speaking. By the way have you cracked the last cipher I sent you. My name is...."
This could be a simple clue leading into his new cipher, however, the author of the letter is highly unlikely to submit his real name. In addition, it is simply too short a code to be verifiable, and the Zodiac Killer must surely have known this if he had any rudimentary knowledge of code breaking. But with a clue or key affixed to the 13 symbol code, then we may have a chance.
Up to this point in time we only knew the murderer by the pseudonym Zodiac, so let us complete the introduction on the April 20th 1970 letter: "This is the Zodiac speaking. By the way have you cracked the last cipher I sent you. My name is Zodiac."  This however sounds a little flawed, so it is imperative we replace Zodiac with an alternative, something possibly embedded within the name Zodiac itself. 

​The 340 cipher has been entered into every powerful computer known to man with no solution being found, leading many people to believe it has no solution at all, and is in effect total 'gibberish.'  I don't know about the entirety of the 340 cipher, but the final twentieth line of the cipher does contain perfect symmetry in six of the final eight characters. In addition eight of the final nine characters are effectively carried forward from the 340 cipher to the 13 Symbol cipher, linking cipher two and cipher three together. In the 13 Symbol cipher he did refer to "
My name is..," so we will look for his pseudonym in the 340 cipher and take this as the clue. 
We already know that six symbols on the twentieth line of the 340 cipher look very similar to his pseudonym Zodiac, but was this unintentional or deliberate. To find this out we shall look at the symmetry of both ciphers.
The 13 symbol cipher from a character standpoint is extremely organized. It starts and ends with three alphabetical characters. The three circled 8's are symmetrically placed in positions 5, 7 and 9. The Zodiac symbol and 'upside down Aries' symbol are four in from either side. Either the Zodiac just happened upon this symmetry, or he designed it for purpose.
Bearing this symmetry in mind, we will look for a symmetrical answer in both the 340 cipher and 13 Symbol cipher, and in addition symmetry between the two.
The Zodiac Killer was undoubtedly an egotist, so it wouldn't be all that surprising if he used his own pseudonym in the clue, and embedded the answer within the name Zodiac. In the following examination I will be using the identical mathematical technique on both the 340 cipher and 13 Symbol cipher, to show perfect symmetry in both instances. It was this egotism that led me to believe the clue resided in the 'near' Zodiac on the twentieth line of the 340 cipher. So using a comparison technique, I placed the proper spelling of Zodiac under the 'near' Zodiac and simply counted the numerical alphabetical difference in the columns. But first let us take a look at the 13 Symbol cipher and note the bottom two lines in the diagram below.
Because of not only the existing symmetry within this cipher, but the fact it was thirteen characters in length, began with an A and ended with an M, along with Zodiac's penchant for word games, it seemed the obvious choice to place the first 13 letters of the alphabet under the cipher. 
A to A = 0, B to E = 3, C to N = 11, F to K = 5, H to M = 5, K to N = 3, A to L = 11. 
It is achieved by staying within the alphabet and counting the numerical distance between the letters. Obviously, when we do not have two alphabetical characters there can be no difference, so a zero is attributed. You could attribute an X, it actually makes no difference to the resulting symmetry.    

Picture
Highlighted in red and green the obvious symmetry can be observed. But how likely can this be created by accident. 
By taking the three circled 8's as H's, it can still be seen that only three natural numbers are ever produced - 3, 1 and 5. 
How do we know if this is the technique that Zodiac employed? If we apply this technique to the 'near' Zodiac on the twentieth line of the 340 cipher using the correct spelling of Zodiac and it again produces perfect symmetry, then we have possibly bolstered our case. If, in addition, it produces something significant that relates to the 13 Symbol cipher, does it then become even more compelling? The most obvious choice this time is to place Zodiac underneath the six symbols on the twentieth line, like so:
Picture
Using the identical technique we used in the 13 Symbol cipher, we shall again count the numerical difference in the columns.
Z to Z = 0, O to O = 0, D to triangle = 0, I to A = 8, A to I = 8, C to K = 8.
That is three 0's and three 8's, carried forward to the 13 Symbol cipher on April 20th 1970. But that is not all.
Either side of the 'near' Zodiac on the twentieth line of the 340 cipher we have the crosshairs and an 'inverted Aries' in part.  
Both of which are situated on the 13 Symbol cipher, either side of the circled 8's (shown in the red rectangular boxes above).
This means, that effectively eight characters out of the last nine were effectively carried forward from the 340 cipher to the 13 symbol cipher. It could be argued that the last eight characters of the 340 cipher were carried forward, the plus sign (+) at the end of the 340 cipher signifying their addition to the 13 Symbol cipher.
​Zodiac is now represented by the three circled 8's. 'In Christian numerology, the number 888 represents Jesus, or sometimes more specifically Christ the Redeemer. This representation may be justified either through gematria, by counting the letter values of the Greek transliteration of Jesus' name, or as an opposing value to 666, the number of the beast.' Wikipedia. This may be important when we consider the Zodiac's tendency to speak of "paradise" and the "afterlife" in many of his communications, in particular his 408 cipher. He would also cross "paradice" and "slaves" in the form of a crucifix on the Halloween card, as well as pasting a red crucifix on the 13 Hole postcard.  
You can see in the above diagram that the letters K and M are embedded within the three 8's and therefore embedded in the name Zodiac. Were these his initials, and was he elevating himself to divine status? He certainly had the ego for it.

# There are some additional features of interest:
The 408 cipher was divided up into three sections of 8 lines and mailed to three different newspapers.
The final line of the 408 cipher contains an M and reversed K.
The final line of the 340 cipher contains an M and reversed K.
The 13 Symbol cipher contains the letter M and K.
The final character at the end of each of the three communications of the 408 cipher is either an M or reversed K.
The top line of the 32 Symbol cipher mailed on 
June 26th 1970 contains an M and reversed K.

Related article: 
http://www.zodiacciphers.com/zodiac-news/peek-through-the-pines
This website contains no advertisements. To help keep it running, any donations, however small, would be greatly appreciated. Thank you. Richard. 

ZODIAC KILLER SERIES ON THE HISTORY CHANNEL

$
0
0
Picture
The History Channel series about the Zodiac Killer will begin on Tuesday November 14th 2017 and run for five consecutive weeks, examining certain aspects of the Zodiac case, promising new findings on the ciphers and more.
The images on the right are of Cheri Jo Bates trousers being tested in the laboratory and the crime scene photograph taken in the Riverside campus alleyway on October 31st 1966.
The promotion attached to the upper image states "AISOCC Review Board Member Suzanna Ryan, Sal LaBarbera and Detective Kenneth Mains used the M-Vac System to extract DNA from clothing of a potential Zodiac victim at our AISOCC Laboratory. What they found after 50 years is shocking....tune into the History Channel on November 14th at 10.00 pm Eastern Standard Time to find out more...."

Suzanna Ryan specializes in forensic serology and DNA analysis, with over 15 years experience in the field. Forensic serology is the detection, classification and study of various bodily fluids such as blood, semen, fecal matter and perspiration, and their relationship to a crime scene.
The M-Vac system is used in such instances when a victim (in our case Cheri Jo Bates) has been grabbed or manhandled, and the perpetrator has left touch DNA, invisible to the naked eye. The M-Vac system is capable of extracting the touch DNA, to enable the laboratory to generate a genetic profile of the suspect. It uses a wet vacuum system in which a buffer will be sprayed onto the trousers, while at the same time the freed particles will be sucked into a collection bottle for testing. It is used when other techniques have failed, such as swabbing and taping. The samples collected may be incredibly small, so polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is often used to amplify the sample. The sample could be semen, skin cells, saliva or blood. "The M-Vac was able to collect anywhere from 36% to 189% more DNA from experimental evidence items such as extremely dilute blood (1:5000 – 1:25,000) on shirts, rocks, and wood and from touch DNA on knit caps and duct tape." Ryan Forensic
Since 2002, when Cydne Holt secured a partial DNA profile of the Zodiac Killer from communications mailed by the killer, the field of forensic DNA analysis has come a long way, including the detection and examination of the male Y-chromosome in mixed samples. "
The Y chromosome DNA testing enables examination of the male-specific portion of biological evidence. This capability can be especially important in situations where a small amount of male DNA may be recovered in the presence of excess female DNA, such as in sexual assault evidence." link.   

PictureThe Hunt for the Zodiac Killer- begins November 14th
This is particularly relevant in the case of Cheri Jo Bates, where small traces of male DNA may be present in the mixed sample on her trousers, which were inevitably laden with her own blood after the savage knife attack in 1966. 
The murderer of Cheri Jo Bates could easily have cut himself while inflicting the numerous injuries on the young woman, either from his hand slipping down the knife as it became soaked with blood, or quite possibly from the knife folding in on itself, had it broke or malfunctioned. The author of the 'Confession' letter did state "I plunged the knife into her and it broke. I then finished the job by cutting her throat." Clearly no knife blade was recovered at autopsy or on the alleyway floor, so if the author of the 'Confession' letter was truthful, it is most likely the killer had a small-bladed pocket knife which could easily have closed onto his fingers or hand, secreting blood onto the clothes of Cheri Jo Bates. 
The promotion material promises "what they found after 50 years is shocking." So, if the hype is to be believed, we would have to assume that the M-Vac system possibly retrieved incriminating DNA evidence, likely from the trousers of Cheri Jo Bates, although one would expect her upper garments are the more likely area to have contained the fingerprint of the killer. However, touch DNA samples can produce erroneous and misleading results, the sample being so incredibly small, it is extremely susceptible  to contamination. Hope you enjoy the series.

THE BIBLE CODE OF A KILLER

$
0
0
PictureCeltic Cross
This is again a modernization of a previous article and the last time I will tackle this subject.
The Zodiac created four ciphers, of which only one has ever been solved and confirmed by overwhelming consensus. 
The third code is simply too short to achieve any meaningful decryption and the 'Button' letter '32 Symbol' code has only three repeating characters, making these two codes, without a key, effectively unbreakable. If we had the key however, then we would be back in business.
​It is perfectly reasonable after the solve by Donald Gene and Bettye June Harden in the August of 1969, to believe that all the remaining ciphers contain a message, after all, what would be the point of them other than a joke on Zodiac's part.
​It is my contention that the remaining three ciphers are all probably linked by religion, and Jesus Christ in particular.
The Zodiac chose a Celtic Cross style moniker, talked of "paradice" and the "afterlife," and placed crucifix style designs in his 'Halloween' and '13 Hole' postcards. You could say the Zodiac Code was the forerunner to the Da Vinci Code.
The key to the Zodiac Code is the previously discussed '13 Symbol' cipher, where the Zodiac splits the alphabet A through M to expose perfect symmetry in the third cipher. This is the template we shall use in the '13 Symbol' and '32 Symbol' ciphers, and in both instances arrive at exactly the same holy number. 
The Zodiac crosshairs can be noted in every cipher or code, so it is imperative we derive a mathematical figure for this moniker. But first we shall present the Zodiac Code that will be used on both ciphers.    

Picture
The alphabet on the right has been split symmetrically into two halves. A through M was used in the Embedded Symmetry article, in which only the numbers 3, 1 and 5 were ever generated. The number 315 can be generated in several ways using the Zodiac Killer communications, but the simplest way is to take the Zodiac horoscope.
The Zodiac used what appeared to be an upside-down Aries symbol on the April 20th 1970  '13 Symbol' cipher. Many people also considered that the three circled 8's were in fact three circled Taurus symbols. But the reason the Zodiac Killer circled them, was possibly so they could be interpreted as both. Since we are dealing with the Zodiac horoscope, we will take the characters as one Aries and three Taurus symbols. 

Picture
On the left is the Zodiac horoscope placed into the Zodiac Code (above).
This generates the figure 315 for the Zodiac crosshairs. 
Because we will be using Aries and Taurus in the '13 Symbol' cipher, I will explain how to arrive at the figures in brackets:
ARIES = A+R+I+E+S = 1+5+5+5+6 = 22.  
TAURUS = T+A+U+R+U+S = 7+1+6+5+6+6 =31.
ARIES =22, TAURUS = 31.

Before we move on it is important to mention the following again.
'In Christian numerology, the number 888 represents Jesus, or sometimes more specifically Christ the Redeemer. This representation may be justified either through gematria, by counting the letter values of the Greek transliteration of Jesus' name, or as an opposing value to 666, the number of the beastWikipedia.
In English gematria the figure for Jesus is 444'.  
If the Zodiac was creating his own bible code and referencing the rebirth of Christ using the number 8 for infinity, one would hope to find the figure 444 in the '13 Symbol' cipher shown below.  

Let us proceed and place the numbers alongside the relevant characters (see below). 
Notice again how the alphabetical characters only produce the figures 3, 1 and 5, as does the figure 315 representing the Zodiac crosshairs. 
The total value of the '13 Symbol' cipher is 444, representing Jesus. 

Picture
We shall now move on to the '32 Symbol' cipher mailed just two months after the previous cipher. It contained only three repeating characters, the letter C, the letter O and the clear triangle, making it impossible to solve without a recognized key.
This led me to believe that these two ciphers were only solvable by some form of mathematical key.
Below I have used the same technique, using the Zodiac Code, representing the letters of the '32 Symbol' cipher by numbers. The Zodiac crosshairs are again attributed the 315 value and the Aries symbol the figure 22 once more. This time however, we have an Omega symbol, so we have to attribute it a figure.
OMEGA = O+M+E+G+A = 2+1+5+7+1 = 16. The six geometric shapes in the '32 Symbol' cipher cannot be attributed a name, and therefore cannot be attributed a value. They have been marked with a red X. 
You can see below, that when the numerical values are added up we arrive at the figure 444 once again.
Zodiac representing the figure 888, and both the remaining ciphers totaling 888. Whether it be 444 or 888, the reference to Jesus or Jesus Christ through the bible code of the Zodiac Killer is certainly possible. 

The '408' cipher was divided up into three parts and mailed to the San Francisco Chronicle, Vallejo Times-Herald and San Francisco Examiner newspapers, but the final 18 characters of this cipher were unable to be decoded. Many speculated as to whether this was just filler to create three equal parts of 8 lines. Was this the rudimentary beginnings of 888, that he would carry through to his remaining ciphers and the name Zodiac itself ? 

http://www.zodiacciphers.com/zodiac-news/340-cipher-embedded-symmetry   

THE EQUINOX LETTER

$
0
0
In 1975, an FBI document detailed a possible Zodiac correspondence, which has become known as the 'Equinox' letter.
The slip of paper was yellow in color and the message was largely handwritten in blue felt tip pen. The style of the writing has more in common with the Zodiac 'Red Phantom' letter rather than his copious other earlier communications, nevertheless it is interesting for a number of reasons, other than the obvious astrology connection.
A man from Fresno, California, handed it in to law enforcement and stated that 'over the July 4th 1975 weekend he had visited his brother-in-law at his residence in Oakland, California. During the visit his brother-in-law had showed him a 1968 Datsun 1600 sports car bearing California license plates, which he said had been given to him a week before by a co-employee. The car had not been driven for some time and had no 1975 registration tags. In the front floorboard of the vehicle he found the enclosed note among some newspapers and other discarded papers. He said he read a good deal about the Zodiac murder case and feels this note may have been written by Zodiac. He advised he further suspects that his brother-in-law may be involved because of his hippy-type life style and because his brother-in-law once told him he was at the scene of the taxicab driver murder in San Francisco the night it occurred and made very discouraging remarks about the police investigation into the matter. He advised he reported this to the Fresno Police Department but did not feel that anything was done with the information, and he, therefore, contacted the FBI with his present information.'       
Picture
The note began with EQUINOX 3:33 pm.
The note appeared to be almost three years old, based on the date September 22nd 1972, offered on the next line.
A quick check of the September 22nd Equinox in 1972 for Oakland, gives us a Pacific Daylight Time (PDT) of 15:32 or 3:32 pm, almost the exact time displayed on the 'Equinox' letter.
At the foot of the note the author has highlighted in bold capitals 'FULL ARIES MOON.' September 22nd 1972 was a full moon. September 22nd is the final day of Virgo in the horoscope calendar. 
The 14th April (4/14/41) falls under the ARIES sign, but there was no full moon in 1941 for this date. It was a full moon on April 11th 1941 in Aries.
It was a new moon on October 11th 1969 when Paul Stine was murdered in San Francisco. 
Seemingly Phil G was an Aries and September 22nd 1972 was a full moon.
The note began with "Equinox 3:33 pm. Can't make it Sat. Nite but the spell is broken & I hope I'll see you more than ever?"
Just under three months prior to this letter Edward J Salmina, sports editor of the Novato Advance received a hand-printed 'death note' signed Zodiac. The newspaper article of June 30th 1972 read 'The hand-printed letter said: "If you leave your house past 3:13:47 on the next ten Saturdays, you will be killed." In the lower left corner under the heading "message" were a series of symbols. Salmina of 25 Crescent Lane told police he didn't know who or why anyone would send him such a letter.'  Crescent Lane is situated in Novato, Marin County, approximately thirty miles from Oakland (where the brother-in-law lived).
The two similarities between the 'Equinox' note and the 'Death' note sent to Edward J Salmina were firstly, the time presented on each correspondence. The first note, sent just prior to June 30th 1972 stated a time of 3:13:47, the second note on September 22nd 1972, a time of 3:33 pm. only 19 minutes difference. The second similarity was the mention of Saturday in both notes. Incidentally, ten Saturdays from the date of the 'Death' note would have been September 2nd 1972, twenty days before the 'Equinox' note. 

Picture
The third event in this 30 mile radius was the attempted murder of Isobel Watson. 
Isobel Watson (33) had just got off the bus on the evening of April 7th 1972, and was walking home along Pine Hill Road, Tamalpais Valley, Marin County at 9.00 pm, when a light colored vehicle veered towards her, knocking her to the ground. [view on google maps]. The driver exited his vehicle offering to take her home, but after she had refused his offer of apparent help a second time, the concerned citizen suddenly became enraged, pulling out a knife and stabbing the woman in the neck and shoulder. ​Her screams alerted the neighborhood, forcing the assailant into a hasty retreat from the scene.
She was treated at Marin General Hospital and fortunately survived the brutal attack.
Her description of the man alerted investigators to a possible Zodiac connection, that of a man with heavy rimmed black glasses, in his early 40's, 5' 9" in height and short brown hair. It was not overlooked by police that the killer had attempted to lure the woman into his vehicle, not dissimilar to the method employed in the Modesto abduction of Kathleen Johns. 
These are three unlikely Zodiac connections, however all three occurred in relatively close proximity to one another within a six month period. 


www.zodiackillersite.com/viewtopic.php?f=78&t=169
http://www.zodiackillersite.com/viewtopic.php?f=78&t=1969

http://www.historyofnovato.com/s-vips

PODCASTS AND THANK YOU

$
0
0
Picture
The first thing I would like to say is a big thank you to all the contributors and visitors to this site over the last five years, and those lately who have kindly made donations to Paypal. It may not seem so, but new Zodiac material is becoming harder and harder to create, as every nook and cranny of the case has been covered extensively and explored in ever minute detail. Having now written over 320 articles since September 2012, it is time to try something different.
​That means moving into podcasts. Primarily these podcasts will cover every aspect of Lake Herman Road, Blue Rock Springs Park, Lake Berryessa, Presidio Heights, the murder of Cheri Jo Bates and the Modesto abduction of Kathleen Johns. But other topics will be covered as well. Some podcasts will be carefully prepared, while others will be done on the fly, unedited and raw. Sometimes it's easier listening to Zodiac material rather than reading it, and it has the added benefits of you being able to doze off to sleep while I go babbling on. If you have any topics or individual features of each crime you would like covered, let me know in comments.
Thanks for your support down the years, Richard. 

Viewing all 1041 articles
Browse latest View live